Introduction

Background

The metaverse concept first appeared in 1992 in the science fiction novel Snow crash by American novelist Neal Stephenson. The characters in Snow crash become avatars and work in a 3-dimensional (3D) virtual reality, and this 3D virtual reality is called the metaverse. The metaverse refers to a virtual reality existing beyond reality. It is a compound word of “meta”, meaning transcendence and virtuality, and “universe”, meaning world and universe. This term refers to the digitized earth as a new world expressed through digital media such as smartphones and the internet [1]. After the concept of the metaverse appeared, extensive efforts and research were carried out to make the metaverse a reality. The Acceleration Studies Foundation (ASF), a representative metaverse research organization, announced the metaverse roadmap in 2006. It presented the concept of the metaverse and the 4 types of the metaverse and proposed thinking about the metaverse as a connection point or combination of the real world and virtual reality.

Go et al. [2] defined the metaverse as “a 3D-based virtual reality in which daily activities and economic life are conducted through avatars representing the real themselves.” Here, daily activities and economic life are extensions of reality, and it is seen that the real world is combined with the virtual space, and reality is expanded into the virtual space. In other words, the avatar in the metaverse is identified with one’s real self. The avatar engages in social, economic, and cultural activities in the metaverse world. In addition, Lee [3] stated that “metaverse means a world in which virtual and reality interact and co-evolve, and social, economic, and cultural activities are carried out in it to create value.” This is not a simple combination of the world and virtual reality, but an interaction; furthermore, the metaverse can denote a world in which daily life and economic activities are conducted in a unified way.

As the metaverse began to be introduced into present life rapidly, some metaverse applications have already been used in education. Therefore, it is necessary to understand the concept and types of the metaverse and examples of its educational applications.

Objectives

This review aims to define the 4 types of the metaverse and explain the potential and limitation of the educational applications of the metaverse. Specifically, the characteristics of the 4 types of metaverse are described with examples. The merits of applications of the metaverse in the educational field are presented. Furthermore, the limitation and disadvantages of the use of the metaverse are discussed. Thus, this review will be able to provide basic insights into the concept of the metaverse for applying it in education.

Four types of the metaverse

In the ASF’s metaverse roadmap, 2 axes were presented to explain the types of the metaverse [4]. One is ‘augmentation versus simulation’, and the other is ‘intimate versus external’ (Fig. 1). Augmentation technology refers to a technology that adds a new function to an existing real system. In the metaverse, augmentation technology superimposes further information on the physical environment that we perceive. Simulation technology, which contrasts with augmented technology, refers to technology that provides a unique environment by modeling reality. Simulation in the metaverse includes various techniques for realizing the simulated world as a place for interaction. In short, augmented technology and simulation can be divided according to whether the information will be implemented in physical reality or virtual reality.

Meanwhile, the metaverse is divided into an inner world and an external world. The inner world focuses on the identity and behavior of an individual or object. Technology is used to achieve completion of the inner world in the metaverse. Individuals or things act using an avatar or digital profiles or act directly in the system, whereby the user has agency in that environment. In contrast, the external world usually focuses on aspects of external reality centered on the user, the subject of the metaverse. Therefore, it includes technology related to displaying information about the user’s surrounding world and how to control it. These internal and external frameworks become another axis for dividing applications based on whether metaverse technology is focused on the user’s inner world or the surrounding world.

The metaverse roadmap categorizes the metaverse into 4 types: augmented reality, lifelogging, mirror world, and virtual reality based on these 2 axes. Table 1 summarizes the definitions, characteristics, application fields, and use cases of each type.

Augmented reality

Augmented reality is a type of augmentation of the external world. It refers to a form of technology that expands the real physical world outside an individual by using a location-aware system and interface with added and layered networked information on spaces we encounter daily [4]. The interfaces that augment the world are divided into Global Positioning System (GPS)-based, marker-based, and see-through-based [5,6]. By utilizing the built-in GPS and Wi-Fi in a mobile device, augmented reality provides linkage information suitable for the user’s location information or recognizes a marker in a QR (quick response) code to augment already extant information. In addition, the real world and virtual graphics can be mixed and viewed in real-time through glasses or lenses. Augmented reality has been evaluated to be effective in learning material that is difficult to observe directly or explain in text, fields that require continuous practice and experience, and fields with high costs and high risk [5]. For example, Cruscope’s Virtuali-Tee is an augmented reality T-shirt that allows students to examine the inside of the human body as if it were an anatomy lab [7] (Fig. 2). Augmented reality simulation content as a representative educational case is related to augmented reality. Simulation plays a role in linking abstract visuals to concrete objects by connecting the context of the real world and virtual objects. In the medical field, various examples of augmented reality technology are emerging. Recently, a research team in a hospital in Seoul developed a spinal surgery platform that applied augmented reality technology in collaboration with university laboratories. This platform uses a real-time projection of a pedicle screw used for spinal fixation on a human body structure as an overlay graphic based on augmented reality [8]. In addition, based on this technology, a spinal surgery education program will be developed to implement an effective education system that can be applied to actual surgery (Fig. 3).

Lifelogging

Lifelogging is a type of augmentation of the inner world. In the world of lifelogging, people use smart devices to record their daily lives on the internet or smartphones. Typical examples of lifelogging include Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram. Recently, there have been services that utilize biometric information stored through wearable devices in the medical field. Some devices link sensors such as Nike Plus to record the amount of exercise or location. This is also a kind of lifelogging. As a representative example, the Classting artificial intelligence (AI) system in Korea is an online class community application called an educational social networking service (SNS). In particular, Classting AI analyzes students’ learning achievements and provides customized learning by level in all subjects [9] (Fig. 4).

Mirror world

The mirror world is a type of simulation of the external world that refers to an informationally enhanced virtual model or “reflection” of the real world [4]. The mirror world is a metaverse where the appearance, information, and structure of the real world are transferred to virtual reality as if reflected in a mirror. However, the expression “efficient expansion” is more appropriate than describing these systems as reproducing the real world [1]. All activities in the real world can be done through the internet or mobile applications, and a mirror world metaverse is a place that makes life in the real world convenient and efficient. Examples of representative mirror worlds used in education include “digital laboratories” and “virtual educational spaces” created in various mirror worlds.

Digital labs

The mirror world metaverse was further activated by the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic. In other words, the biggest contributor to enabling the mirror world is the user. Users meet and play games with physically distant people in the mirror world and perform meaningful tasks. The Foldit platform provides an opportunity for all participants to contribute to scientific research through games. David Baker’s team at the University of Washington, which studies protein structure, has used this digital lab to have people fold protein amino acid chains. Through this game, where the protrusion structure matches well, and the player gets points and ranks up if they succeed, the protein structure is found for an AIDS (acquired immunodeficiency syndrome) treatment, and the achievement of 60,000 participants in 10 days was described in a journal publication [10] (Fig. 5).

Virtual educational spaces

A representative example of the mirror world is video conferencing systems such as Zoom, Webex, Google Meet, and Teams. These video conferencing systems are playing the role of the classroom in the real-time operation of non-face-to-face remote classes in the post-COVID-19 era. Gathertown is an online video conferencing platform that supports conversation and business in a virtual space [11]. Its main functions include chatting, interworking with external links, and decorating spaces (Fig. 6). The mirror world metaverse has great educational potential as a way to efficiently expand the information and functions required for learning while showing the real world exactly as if reflected in a mirror [1].

Virtual reality

Virtual reality is a type of the metaverse that simulates the inner world. Virtual reality technology includes sophisticated 3D graphics, avatars, and instant communication tools. It is a world where users feel that they are entirely in a virtual reality. Virtual reality is often described as the other end of the spectrum containing mixed reality and augmented reality [12]. However, virtual reality makes us see a flat image in 3 dimensions based on the working principle of our eyes [6]. It is also characterized as an internet-based 3D space that multiple users can access simultaneously and participate by creating an avatar that expresses the user’s self [13].

In this virtual reality metaverse, the space, cultural background, characters, and institutions are designed differently from in reality. The avatar that acts on behalf of the user explores a virtual space with AI characters, communicates with other players, and achieves the goal. Virtual reality is also called the metaverse in the narrow sense in that the real body moves, touches something, and daily and economic activities take place in the virtual space. Zepeto and Roblox are examples of virtual reality [14,15]. Zepeto is a 3D avatar-based interactive service that has recently appeared, and Roblox is a platform where anyone can create virtual reality and create games by themselves to enjoy with friends and engage in various creative experiences [16].

Zepeto is an augmented reality avatar service operated by Naver Z, and is a representative metaverse platform in Korea. Zepeto, launched in 2018, creates a “3D avatar” using facial recognition, augmented reality, and 3D technology to communicate with other users. It allows users to experience various virtual realities. When anyone takes a picture or loads an image saved in his or her smartphone, a character that resembles the user is created through AI technology. They can customize skin color, features, height, facial expression, gestures, and fashion style as they like. Since the SNS function is also incorporated, it is possible to follow other people and to exchange messages by text or voice [14]. Various activities such as games and educational role-plays can be performed through multiple maps. For example, a teacher can select a classroom map, open a room, invite students, and interact with each other by voice or message on the classroom map [14] (Fig. 7).

Roblox is a virtual reality platform launched in 2006, where one can create one’s own space and enjoy games in real-time. Lee and Han [17] explain that Roblox is a “second real world” in which the virtual currency “Robux” is used, and the economic ecosystem is completed. It is characterized by users being able to make games on their own in virtual reality using the Lego-shaped avatar or to enjoy games made by others [15] (Fig. 8).

Convergence and complexity of the metaverse

We have looked at the characteristics and examples of each of the 4 types of the metaverse. The metaverse can be organized as a space in which the real world is augmented by virtual reality. The real world is connected to virtual reality, the real world is replicated in virtual reality, or the virtual reality becomes another world. From a functional point of view, the metaverse integrates information retrieval, SNS, and game elements. From an evolutionary point of view, the metaverse is a mixture of the internet with 5G and virtual convergence technology, reflecting a world that has been spread and developed in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. From a technical point of view, the metaverse is a complex of virtual reality technologies [2]. Socially, it is a space where members of the digital native generation leave traces in their daily life and economic life with their various appearances (personas, avatars) in the 3D-based internet world. Table 2 summarizes the characteristics and educational implications of each type of metaverse discussed above.

The core of the metaverse can be seen as “extension” and “connection.” The 4 types of the metaverse were developed independently in the beginning. Nonetheless, they have recently been evolving into a new kind of convergence/composite service by interacting while breaking down boundaries. For example, Ghost Pacer, presented as lifelogging, combines augmented reality and lifelogging service [3]. In addition, the virtual conference service Roomkey [18] introduced in a mirror world is an example of the fusion of lifelogging, the mirror world, and virtual reality. Existing non-face-to-face meetings such as video conferences and webinars have the disadvantage that there is no proper way to measure performance other than the number of simultaneous users. In this service that combines virtual reality and lifelogging concepts in a mirror world, all activities such as meetings and networking are measured after the performance.

Characteristics of the virtual reality metaverse in education

Among the 4 types of the metaverse, the most diverse and actively used technology in education is virtual reality. In particular, the recent non-face-to-face (untact) era has been characterized by the frequent the utilization of virtual reality, , which can be accessed from anywhere regardless of distance or space. Go et al. [2] presented 5 characteristics of the virtual reality metaverse that distinguish it from existing platform services as the “5 Cs” as follows: first, as a canon, the space-time of the metaverse is created and expanded by designers and participants together; second, a creator (anyone in the metaverse) can create content; third, as a digital currency, production and consumption are possible through the production of various contents; fourth, the continuity of everyday life is guaranteed through the metaverse; and fifth, the metaverse connects the real and the virtual, connects the metaverse worlds, and connects people (avatars).

Book [19] also suggested 6 characteristics of virtual reality as follows: first, as a shared space, virtual reality should be a space where multiple users can participate at the same time; second, with a graphical user interface, virtual reality is visually expressed and implemented in a 2-dimensional (2D) or 3D environment; third, immediacy means that interactions between users in the virtual reality occur in real-time; fourth, interactivity allows users to interact with various contents of the virtual reality, such as transforming or developing contents; fifth, the virtual reality is persistently maintained regardless of the access of individual users; and sixth, with socialization/community, a community that can perform various social actions in the virtual reality can be formed.

Potential of the metaverse as an educational environment

The recent metaverse craze has started again, according to the transition to an untact society due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The 4 existing metaverse types—augmented reality, lifelogging, mirror world, and virtual reality—are accelerating the utilization of the metaverse as it evolves into a new type of convergence service. It also breaks down the boundaries between these types of the metaverse. As face-to-face communication becomes difficult due to the spread of COVID-19, activities that were thought to be only possible offline are being converted to virtual reality and are rapidly expanding into various fields such as education, medical care, fashion, and tourism.

A space for new social communication

Due to the prolonged COVID-19 pandemic, it is not easy to have private meetings of many people or eat together in a restaurant. However, in the metaverse, hundreds of thousands or tens of millions of people can gather to hold a festival or watch a concert by their favorite singer. Virtual reality metaverses such as Roblox and Zepeto provided people who could not go out due to COVID-19 with a new social space for meeting and relaxation.

When schools were closed due to COVID-19 and students could not attend school, the “Classroom Map” among various 3D maps in Zepeto was the most popular. Instead of going to the real classroom, the students went to the Zepeto classroom. They met and communicated with their friends. The idol group Blackpink held a virtual fan signing event through Zepeto when they could not hold a fan signing event face-to-face due to COVID-19. Blackpink also released a choreography music video for “Ice cream” that they reproduced with their avatar [20] (https://gweb.zepeto.io/user/post/97321663). More than 46 million users attended Blackpink’s virtual fan signing event to get autographs and take selfies with their favorite singers. The idol group BTS also held a showcase by releasing the choreography version of the music video for “Dynamite” on Fortnite for the first time [21]. Users who attended the event forgot about COVID-19 and enjoyed the event by dancing together or sharing their impressions.

A higher degree of freedom to create and share

Some may believe the metaverse to be merely online games, but it is an evolved concept. In online games, service users have no choice but to perform limited missions according to the goals set by the platform provider. However, in the metaverse, ultimately, anything the user wants is possible without a pre-determined mission. Based on the perfect degree of freedom, users can experience various things in the real world, such as study, shopping, performances, exhibitions, and tourism. They can also share events that are difficult to experience easily due to physical restrictions in the real world, such as flying in the sky and going to space. Alternatively, users can get away from their busy lives and enjoy the leisurely life of fishing, picking fruits, or traveling to a friend’s island all day without the task of solving the metaverse. Everything is the user’s choice.

By actively utilizing the characteristics of the metaverse, it will be possible to design learning activities that can expand students’ freedom and experience to an infinite extent. Students will conduct self-directed learning that allows them to explore their questions based on their endless autonomy. They can refer to the ideas of countless people across time and space and take the initiative in finding their original answers.

Providing new experiences and high immersion through virtualization

The metaverse is attracting attention as an alternative to overcome the limitations of existing 2D-based online and remote classes. It can provide a differentiated experience value from the current internet era due to the complex use of various technologies. Furthermore, the metaverse makes it possible to design a new experience that transcends time and space. Metaverse-based education enables the use of infinite space and data and has the advantage of allowing interaction at the level of face-to-face education [3].

Limitations of the metaverse in educational application

The metaverse has made users “social connection” possible by providing a place where people with hobbies and interests can gather and communicate even under real-world restrictions such as “social distancing” in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. However, these social connections in the metaverse are weaker than interactions in the real world. In metaverse, rather than showing “me as I am,” information that one does not want to share is deleted to create “me I want to show.” In addition, privacy infringement is also a problem that needs to be considered in social activities in the metaverse, where various information that was not generated in real-world interactions is collected and processed in real-time.

The high degree of freedom, which is an advantage of the metaverse, makes metaverse users more dangerous than users of existing online services and games. The administrator cannot predict all the actions of users due to the high degree of freedom. Due to the essential characteristics of the metaverse—virtual space and anonymity—people’s sense of guilt about crimes is reduced. There is a concern that new crimes that are more vicious and sophisticated than the real world may appear. The ‘I’ participating in the virtual world may have a similar appearance and self as an extension of reality, but may participate as a self with a different appearance and worldview. The term sub-character (additional character) can be interpreted as the concept of an avatar. As life in which the virtual world and reality are combined become commonplace, the degree of freedom in people’s identities is expected to increase gradually in a virtual space where one’s identity is not exposed at all. People can be recognized in a limited way compared to reality. They should be careful because they can be more easily exposed to criminal activities in the metaverse with a higher level of anonymity. In a metaverse that values freedom, the countless amounts of data created and shared by users worldwide cannot be censored one by one. Therefore, there is a possibility that it will become a lawless zone. In this case, caution is needed because it can be a significant risk to young adolescents with little social experience and whose identity has not been established. Furthermore, ethics education for cultivating citizenship in the virtual world will be required.

As the distinction between the virtual and the real world becomes blurred, users may experience confusion regarding their “real me” identity. They may not be able to adapt to virtual reality properly appropriately. If one is too immersed in human relationships in the virtual reality or satisfied with human relationships in virtual reality, there is a danger that neglecting one’s relationships in the real world can make them worse, or it can make it difficult to establish relationships (Table 3).

Conclusion

The characteristics of 4 types of the metaverse, the possibility of educational applications, the convergence and complex characteristics of the types of the metaverse, and the potential and limitations of the metaverse for educational applications were described. The metaverse is predicted to change our daily life and economy beyond the realm of games and entertainment. Furthermore, all social, cultural, and economic activities are moving to the metaverse’s new platform. The metaverse has infinite potential as a new social communication space. It provides a high degree of freedom for creation and sharing and provides a unique and immersive experience [22] (Fig. 9). Since the metaverse is expected to grow rapidly during and after the COVID-19 pandemic, it also has risk factors that do not have appropriate regulations. The following are suggested as future tasks for the educational use of the metaverse.

First, it is necessary to carefully analyze how students understand the metaverse, what they want to do there, why they like it, and what value they attach to their avatar in virtual reality. It is necessary to study students’ activity patterns, level of immersion in the metaverse, and its positive and negative effects on students' learning activities.

Second, an effective and attractive aspect of the metaverse is that it allows us to experience events that would be impossible or limited in the real world. However, there is room for uncritically accepting the intentions of content developers or service designers rather than students’ cognitive abilities and imagination. Therefore, instructional designers and instructors who want to utilize the metaverse for education need to properly understand each type of metaverse’s technical characteristics and design classes so that they can solve problems or perform projects collaboratively and creatively.

Third, developing an educational metaverse platform to prevent the misuse of student data is required. Evaluation studies on data collection to support teaching and learning are also required.

Article information

Authors’ contributions

All work was done by all authors.

Conflict of interest

Bokyung Kye, Na-Ra Han, Eun-Ji Kim, and So Young Jo have been employees of the Korea Education and Research Information Service. However, this review article is not an official opinion of the Korea Education and Research Information Service, but rather reflects the authors’ opinions. Otherwise, no potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.

Funding

None.

Data availability

None.

Acknowledgments

Supplementary materials

Article information

Editors’ note

The metaverse is a new and unique environment in health education. Although the application of the metaverse in health education is still uncommon, there have already been some cases of its application. The evaluation of metaverse applications is another emerging topic, the relevance of which was accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic. This review article can serve as an introductory guide for health educators to the metaverse’s possibilities for educational applications.

Fig. 1.

(A, B) Diagram of 4 types of the metaverse [4].

Fig. 2.

Virtuali-Tee: augmented reality T-Shirt [7].

Fig. 3.

Augmented reality-based spine surgery platform [8].

Fig. 4.

(A, B) Artificial intelligence analysis screen for all subjects and distribution table of achievement changes by unit [9].

Fig. 5.

(A, B) Foldit platform as a mirror world example [10].

Fig. 6.

Classroom in Gathertown [11].

Fig. 7.

Class 2 map in Zepeto. From Snow Corp. Zepeto [Internet]. Seongnam: Snow Corp.; c2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://zepeto.me/ [14].

Fig. 8.

(A–D) Roblox remote education tool (https://education.roblox.com/ko-kr/resources/roblox-remote). From Roblox Corp. Roblox [Internet]. San Mateo (CA): Roblox Corp.; c2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://www.roblox.com [15].

Fig. 9.

Trends of interest in the metaverse in Google Trends over time. From Google Trends. Metaverse [Internet]. Mountain View (CA): Google; 2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=metaverse [22].

References

• 1. Kim S. Metaverse: digital world, world of emerging items. Hwaseong: PlanB Design; 2020. p. 376 p.
• 2. Go SY, Jeong HG, Kim JI, Sin YT. Concept and developmental direction of metaverse. Korea Inf Process Soc Rev [Internet]. 2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29];28:7-16. Available from: http://www.koreascience.kr/article/JAKO202122450520317.pdf
• 3. Lee S. Log in Metaverse: revolution of human×space×time (IS-115) [Internet]. Seongnam: Software Policy & Research Institute; 2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://spri.kr/posts/view/23165?code=issue_reports
• 4. Smart J, Cascio J, Paffendorf J. Metaverse roadmap: pathway to the 3D web [Internet]. Ann Arbor (MI): Acceleration Studies Foundation; 2007 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://metaverseroadmap.org/MetaverseRoadmapOverview.pdf
• 5. Han S, Lim CI. Research trends on augmented reality education in Korea from 2008 to 2019. J Educ Technol 2020;36:505-528. https://doi.org/10.17232/KSET.36.3.505 Article
• 6. Jung EJ, Kim NH. Virtual and augmented reality for vocational education: a review of major Issues. J Educ Inf Media 2021;27:79-109. https://doi.org/10.15833/KAFEIAM.27.1.079 Article
• 7. Curiscope. Virtuali-Tee: augmented reality T-Shirt [Internet]. Sanford (NC): Curiscope; 2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://www.curiscope.com/
• 8. Park MS. Seoul National University Bundang Hospital, development of AR technology-based spine surgery platform. Etoday [Internet]. 2021 Jan 11 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://www.etoday.co.kr/news/view/1982781
• 9. Classiting. Artificial intelligence analysis screen for all subjects and distribution table of achievement change by unit [Internet]. Seoul: Classiting; c2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://www.classting.ai/
• 10. Khatib F, Cooper S, Kazmierczyk M, Gilski M, Krzywda S, Zabranska H, Pichova I, Thompson J, Popović Z, Jaskolski M, Baker D. Crystal structure of a monomeric retroviral protease solved by protein folding game players. Nat Struct Mol Biol 2011;18:1175-1177. https://doi.org/10.1038/nsmb.2119 ArticlePubMedPMC
• 11. Gather. Classroom in Gathertown [Internet]. San Bruno (CA): Gather; c2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://gather.town/
• 12. Milgram P, Kishino F. A taxonomy of mixed reality visual displays. IEICE Trans Inf Syst 1994;77:1321-1329.
• 13. Han HW. A study on typology of virtual world and its development in metaverse. J Digit Contents Soc 2008;9:317-323.
• 14. Snow Corp. Zepeto [Internet]. Seongnam: Snow Corp.; c2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://zepeto.me/
• 15. Roblox Corp. Roblox [Internet]. San Mateo (CA): Roblox Corp.; c2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://www.roblox.com
• 16. Long RU. Roblox and effect on education [master’s thesis]. Springfield (MO): Drury University; 2019.
• 17. Lee S, Han SH. Metaverse begins: five issues and perspectives (IS-116) [Internet]. Seongnam: Software Policy & Research Institute; 2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://spri.kr/posts/view/23197?code=issue_reports
• 18. Roomkey. Roomkey [Internet]. London: Roomkey; c2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://www.facebook.com/Roomkeyapp/
• 19. Book B. In moving beyond the game: social virtual worlds. Proceedings of the Culture of Play at the Conference State of Play 2; 2004 Oct 28-30; New York, USA. New York (NY): New York Law School; 2004.
• 20. Blackpink. Icecream [Internet]. Seongnam: Snow Corp.; 2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://gweb.zepeto.io/user/post/97321663
• 21. BTS. Dynamite in Fortnite [Internet]. Cary (NC): Epic Games Inc.; 2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://www.epicgames.com/fortnite/en-US/creative/island-codes/bts-dynamite-0272-4337-3889
• 22. Google Trends. Metaverse [Internet]. Mountain View (CA): Google; 2021 [cited 2021 Nov 29]. Available from: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=metaverse

Figure & Data

References

Citations

Citations to this article as recorded by  

• How do the news media, academia, and the public view the metaverse? Evidence from South Korea
  Youngju Kim, Bumsoo Kim
  Technological Forecasting and Social Change.2024; 198: 122980.     CrossRef
• CardioVerse: The cardiovascular medicine in the era of Metaverse
  Ioannis Skalidis, Olivier Muller, Stephane Fournier
  Trends in Cardiovascular Medicine.2023; 33(8): 471.     CrossRef
• Editorial commentary: CardioVerse: Buying the stairway to heaven
  Antonio Sánchez-Puente, P. Ignacio Dorado-Díaz, Pedro L Sánchez
  Trends in Cardiovascular Medicine.2023; 33(8): 477.     CrossRef
• A scoping review of metaverse in emergency medicine
  Tzu-Chi Wu, Chien-Ta Bruce Ho
  Australasian Emergency Care.2023; 26(1): 75.     CrossRef
• A new universe in Dermatology: From metaverse to Dermoverse
  Miriam Fernández‐Parrado, Héctor Perandones‐González
  Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Who really needs a Metaverse in anatomy education? A review with preliminary survey results
  Joe Iwanaga, Edward C. Muo, Yoko Tabira, Koichi Watanabe, Susan J. Tubbs, Anthony V. D'Antoni, Mathangi Rajaram‐Gilkes, Marios Loukas, Mohammed K. Khalil, R. Shane Tubbs
  Clinical Anatomy.2023; 36(1): 77.     CrossRef
• Social rather than physical crowding reduces the required interpersonal distance in virtual environments
  Ming Han, Xue‐Min Wang, Shu‐Guang Kuai
  PsyCh Journal.2023; 12(1): 34.     CrossRef
• Blockchain‐based asset storage and service mechanism to metaverse universe: Metarepo
  Mevlüt Ersoy, Remzi Gürfidan
  Transactions on Emerging Telecommunications Technologies.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• A Bodies‐On Museum: The Transformation of Museum Embodiment through Virtual Technology
  Siyi Wang
  Curator: The Museum Journal.2023; 66(1): 107.     CrossRef
• A trustless architecture of blockchain-enabled metaverse
  Minghui Xu, Yihao Guo, Qin Hu, Zehui Xiong, Dongxiao Yu, Xiuzhen Cheng
  High-Confidence Computing.2023; 3(1): 100088.     CrossRef
• Facing the challenges of metaverse: a systematic literature review from Social Sciences and Marketing and Communication
  Verónica Crespo-Pereira, Eva Sánchez-Amboage, Matías Membiela-Pollán
  El Profesional de la información.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Utilizing the metaverse in anatomy and physiology
  Christian Moro
  Anatomical Sciences Education.2023; 16(4): 574.     CrossRef
• A systematic review on the metaverse-based blended English learning
  Ming Li, Zhonggen Yu
  Frontiers in Psychology.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• The Medical Metaverse, Part 1: Introduction, Definitions, and New Horizons for Neuropsychiatry
  Wilfredo López-Ojeda, Robin A. Hurley
  The Journal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences.2023; 35(1): A4.     CrossRef
• Dijital Oyunların Geleceğinde Metaverse Etkisi
  Mevlüt Hürol METE
  TRT Akademi.2023; 8(17): 294.     CrossRef
• The Use of Virtual Worlds in the Field of Education: A Bibliometric Study
  Ali BATTAL, Abdulkadir TAŞDELEN
  Participatory Educational Research.2023; 10(1): 408.     CrossRef
• Metaverse in Healthcare Integrated with Explainable AI and Blockchain: Enabling Immersiveness, Ensuring Trust, and Providing Patient Data Security
  Sikandar Ali, Abdullah, Tagne Poupi Theodore Armand, Ali Athar, Ali Hussain, Maisam Ali, Muhammad Yaseen, Moon-Il Joo, Hee-Cheol Kim
  Sensors.2023; 23(2): 565.     CrossRef
• Metaverse: A Potential Virtual-Physical Ecosystem for Innovative Blended Education and Training
  Susanta MİTRA
  Journal of Metaverse.2023; 3(1): 66.     CrossRef
• A Second Life for Educators: A Hybrid Extended Reality Education Between Zuckerberg’s Vision and Educational Researchers’ Imaginary
  Mandi Lİ
  Journal of Metaverse.2023; 3(1): 73.     CrossRef
• Security and Privacy in Metaverse: A Comprehensive Survey
  Yan Huang, Yi Joy Li, Zhipeng Cai
  Big Data Mining and Analytics.2023; 6(2): 234.     CrossRef
• Envisioning Architecture of Metaverse Intensive Learning Experience (MiLEx): Career Readiness in the 21st Century and Collective Intelligence Development Scenario
  Eman AbuKhousa, Mohamed Sami El-Tahawy, Yacine Atif
  Future Internet.2023; 15(2): 53.     CrossRef
• Training Scientific Communication Skills on Medical Imaging within the Virtual World Second Life: Perception of Biomedical Engineering Students
  Andrés Lozano-Durán, Teodoro Rudolphi-Solero, Enrique Nava-Baro, Miguel Ruiz-Gómez, Francisco Sendra-Portero
  International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2023; 20(3): 1697.     CrossRef
• An Empirical Study of A Smart Education Model Enabled by the Edu-Metaverse to Enhance Better Learning Outcomes for Students
  Xiaoyang Shu, Xiaoqing Gu
  Systems.2023; 11(2): 75.     CrossRef
• The metaverse training room for cardiovascular interventional surgery
  Tai-Cheng Liu, Ai-Shi Liu, Zhi-Gang Bai, Lei Zhao
  Asian Journal of Surgery.2023; 46(7): 2780.     CrossRef
• Metaverse!
  Tawseef Ahmad Naqishbandi, E. Syed Mohamed, Guido Veronese
  International Journal of E-Adoption.2023; 15(2): 1.     CrossRef
• How do Plastic Surgeons use the Metaverse: A Systematic Review
  Pengfei Sun, Shanbaga Zhao, Yang Yang, Chao Liu, Bo Pan
  Journal of Craniofacial Surgery.2023; 34(2): 548.     CrossRef
• Metaverse as a Learning Environment: Some Considerations
  Maria José Sá, Sandro Serpa
  Sustainability.2023; 15(3): 2186.     CrossRef
• BEDEN EĞİTİMİ ÖĞRETMENLERİNİN METAVERSE BİLGİ DÜZEYLERİNİN ÇEŞİTLİ DEĞİŞKENLERE GÖRE İNCELENMESİ
  Murat TURAN, Muhammet MAVİBAŞ, Buğra Çağatay SAVAŞ, Harun ÇETİN
  The Online Journal of Recreation and Sports.2023; 12(1): 25.     CrossRef
• Time to Think “Meta”: A Critical Viewpoint on the Risks and Benefits of Virtual Worlds for Mental Health
  Vincent Paquin, Manuela Ferrari, Harmehr Sekhon, Soham Rej
  JMIR Serious Games.2023; 11: e43388.     CrossRef
• Metaverse applied to musculoskeletal pathology: Orthoverse and Rehabverse
  Juan M. Román-Belmonte, E. Carlos Rodríguez-Merchán, Hortensia De la Corte-Rodríguez
  Postgraduate Medicine.2023; 135(5): 440.     CrossRef
• Metaverse for Healthcare: A Survey on Potential Applications, Challenges and Future Directions
  Rajeswari Chengoden, Nancy Victor, Thien Huynh-The, Gokul Yenduri, Rutvij H. Jhaveri, Mamoun Alazab, Sweta Bhattacharya, Pawan Hegde, Praveen Kumar Reddy Maddikunta, Thippa Reddy Gadekallu
  IEEE Access.2023; 11: 12765.     CrossRef
• The rising trend of Metaverse in education: challenges, opportunities, and ethical considerations
  Sanaa Kaddoura, Fatima Al Husseiny
  PeerJ Computer Science.2023; 9: e1252.     CrossRef
• When Internet of Things Meets Metaverse: Convergence of Physical and Cyber Worlds
  Kai Li, Yingping Cui, Weicai Li, Tiejun Lv, Xin Yuan, Shenghong Li, Wei Ni, Meryem Simsek, Falko Dressler
  IEEE Internet of Things Journal.2023; 10(5): 4148.     CrossRef
• Emergence of the metaverse and ChatGPT in journal publishing after the COVID-19 pandemic
  Sun Huh
  Science Editing.2023; 10(1): 1.     CrossRef
• Improving Oral Presentation Skills for Radiology Residents through Clinical Session Meetings in the Virtual World Second Life
  Alberto Pino-Postigo, Dolores Domínguez-Pinos, Rocío Lorenzo-Alvarez, José Pavía-Molina, Miguel Ruiz-Gómez, Francisco Sendra-Portero
  International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2023; 20(6): 4738.     CrossRef
• Metaverse Çağında Öğretmenlik Mesleğinin Geleceğini Düşünmek
  Zeynep KAYA
  Mevzu – Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi.2023; (9): 295.     CrossRef
• Virtual neurosurgery anatomy laboratory: A collaborative and remote education experience in the metaverse
  Nicolas I. Gonzalez-Romo, Giancarlo Mignucci-Jiménez, Sahin Hanalioglu, Muhammet Enes Gurses, Siyar Bahadir, Yuan Xu, Grant Koskay, Michael T. Lawton, Mark C. Preul
  Surgical Neurology International.2023; 14: 90.     CrossRef
• Metaverse for climbing the ladder toward ‘Industry 5.0’ and ‘Society 5.0’?
  Ahmed Tlili, Ronghuai Huang, Kinshuk
  The Service Industries Journal.2023; 43(3-4): 260.     CrossRef
• NeuroVerse: neurosurgery in the era of Metaverse and other technological breakthroughs
  Mrinmoy Kundu, Jyi Cheng Ng, Wireko Andrew Awuah, Helen Huang, Rohan Yarlagadda, Aashna Mehta, Esther Patience Nansubuga, Riaz Jiffry, Toufik Abdul-Rahman, Brian M Ou Yong, Vladyslav Sikora, Arda Isik
  Postgraduate Medical Journal.2023; 99(1170): 240.     CrossRef
• Future of virtual education and telementoring
  Ian Seddon, Eric Rosenberg, Steve K. Houston
  Current Opinion in Ophthalmology.2023; 34(3): 255.     CrossRef
• Improving Humanization through Metaverse-Related Technologies: A Systematic Review
  Maria Gonzalez-Moreno, Paula Andrade-Pino, Carlos Monfort-Vinuesa, Antonio Piñas-Mesa, Esther Rincon
  Electronics.2023; 12(7): 1727.     CrossRef
• Exploring problem-based learning curricula in the metaverse: The hospitality students' perspective
  Namhee Lee, Mina Jo
  Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism Education.2023; 32: 100427.     CrossRef
• Considering the Consequences of Cybersickness in Immersive Virtual Reality Rehabilitation: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
  Xin Li, Ding-Bang Luh, Ruo-Hui Xu, Yi An
  Applied Sciences.2023; 13(8): 5159.     CrossRef
• Beyond Your Sight Using Metaverse Immersive Vision With Technology Behaviour Model
  Poh Soon JosephNg, Xiaoxue Gong, Narinderjit Singh, Toong Hai Sam, Hua Liu, Koo Yuen Phan
  Journal of Cases on Information Technology.2023; 25(1): 1.     CrossRef
• Students’ Perception of Metaverses for Online Learning in Higher Education: Hype or Hope?
  Elisa Rojas, Xenia Hülsmann, Rosa Estriegana, Frank Rückert, Soraya Garcia-Esteban
  Electronics.2023; 12(8): 1867.     CrossRef
• Current Perspective of Metaverse Application in Medical Education, Research and Patient Care
  Irene Suh, Tess McKinney, Ka-Chun Siu
  Virtual Worlds.2023; 2(2): 115.     CrossRef
• Metaverse for education – Virtual or real?
  Sajjad Hussain
  Frontiers in Education.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• A Bibliometric Analysis of the Use of the Metaverse in Education Over Three Decades
  Wentao Chen, Jinyu Zhang, Zhonggen Yu
  International Journal of Information and Communication Technology Education.2023; 19(1): 1.     CrossRef
• Exploring the Potential of Metaverse for Higher Education: Opportunities, Challenges, and Implications
  Amrita Prakash, Alimul Haque, Farheen Islam, Deepa Sonal
  Metaverse Basic and Applied Research.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Immersive time (ImT): Conceptualizing time spent in the metaverse
  Emmanuel Mogaji, Jochen Wirtz, Russell W. Belk, Yogesh K. Dwivedi
  International Journal of Information Management.2023; 72: 102659.     CrossRef
• Effects of metaverse-based career mentoring for nursing students: a mixed methods study
  Yujeong Kim, Mi Young Kim
  BMC Nursing.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• New Approach to Design and Assess Metaverse Environments for Improving Learning Processes in Higher Education: The Case of Architectural Construction and Rehabilitation
  Belén Onecha, Còssima Cornadó, Jordi Morros, Oriol Pons
  Buildings.2023; 13(5): 1340.     CrossRef
• The Metaverse and complex thinking: opportunities, experiences, and future lines of research
  Carlos Enrique George-Reyes, Iris Cristina Peláez Sánchez, Leonardo David Glasserman-Morales, Edgar Omar López-Caudana
  Frontiers in Education.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Development and testing of a scale for examining factors affecting the learning experience in the Metaverse
  Emmanuel Fokides
  Computers & Education: X Reality.2023; 2: 100025.     CrossRef
• Metaverse as a Platform for Event Management: The Sample of the Metaverse Türkiye E-Magazine
  Simge ÜNLÜ, Lütfiye YAŞAR, Erdal BİLİCİ
  TRT Akademi.2023; 8(17): 122.     CrossRef
• Using the metaverse in training: lessons from real cases
  Omaima Hajjami, Sunyoung Park
  European Journal of Training and Development.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Development of a Framework for Metaverse in Education: A Systematic Literature Review Approach
  Rita Roy, Mohammad Dawood Babakerkhell, Subhodeep Mukherjee, Debajyoti Pal, Suree Funilkul
  IEEE Access.2023; 11: 57717.     CrossRef
• Blockchain and its derived technologies shape the future generation of digital businesses: A focus on decentralized finance and the Metaverse
  Saeed Banaeian Far, Azadeh Imani Rad, Maryam Rajabzadeh Assar
  Data Science and Management.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Web-Based 3D Virtual Environments Utilization in Primary and Secondary Education of Children with Multiple Impairments
  Branislav Sobota, Štefan Korečko, Miriama Mattová
  Electronics.2023; 12(13): 2792.     CrossRef
• Metaverse Chronicles: A Bibliometric Analysis of Its Evolving Landscape
  Walton Wider, Leilei Jiang, Jiaming Lin, Muhammad Ashraf Fauzi, Jingjing Li, Choon Kit Chan
  International Journal of Human–Computer Interaction.2023; : 1.     CrossRef
• Mapping Metaverse Research: Identifying Future Research Areas Based on Bibliometric and Topic Modeling Techniques
  Abderahman Rejeb, Karim Rejeb, Horst Treiblmaier
  Information.2023; 14(7): 356.     CrossRef
• Eğitim 5.0’a Geçişin Engelli Öğrenciler ve Erişilebilirlik Açısından Etkileri
  Mustafa Özhan KALAÇ, Murat KILINÇ
  Üniversite Araştırmaları Dergisi.2023; 6(3): 229.     CrossRef
• Virtual agents and risk-taking behavior in adolescence: the twofold nature of nudging
  Cinzia Di Dio, Federico Manzi, Laura Miraglia, Michaela Gummerum, Simone Bigozzi, Davide Massaro, Antonella Marchetti
  Scientific Reports.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Research streams and open challenges in the metaverse
  Carmen Carrión
  The Journal of Supercomputing.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Powered education based on Metaverse: Pre- and post-COVID comprehensive review
  M. Alfiras, Janaki Bojiah, M. N. Mohammed, Firas Mohammed Ibrahim, Husham M. Ahmed, Oday I. Abdullah
  Open Engineering.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Metaverse: Literature Review, Synthesis and Future Research Agenda
  Hui Gao, Alain Yee Loong Chong, Haijun Bao
  Journal of Computer Information Systems.2023; : 1.     CrossRef
• Changing learning paradigms: an interplay of Digital Taylorism and technostress on perceived employability
  Harshleen Kaur Duggal, Puja Khatri, Asha Thomas, Marco Pironti
  Journal of Management History.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Using WebXR Metaverse Platforms to Create Touristic Services and Cultural Promotion
  Ana Martí-Testón, Adolfo Muñoz, Luis Gracia, J. Ernesto Solanes
  Applied Sciences.2023; 13(14): 8544.     CrossRef
• Investigation of learners’ behavioral intentions to use metaverse learning environment in higher education: a virtual computer laboratory
  Emin İbili, Melek Ölmez, Abdullah Cihan, Fırat Bilal, Aysel Burcu İbili, Nurullah Okumus, Mark Billinghurst
  Interactive Learning Environments.2023; : 1.     CrossRef
• Innovating Industrial Training with Immersive Metaverses: A Method for Developing Cross-Platform Virtual Reality Environments
  Lucas G. G. Almeida, Nalini V. de Vasconcelos, Ingrid Winkler, Márcio F. Catapan
  Applied Sciences.2023; 13(15): 8915.     CrossRef
• EĞİTİM ODAKLI SANAL EVREN TASARIMI: YILDIZ TEKNİK ÜNİVERSİTESİ ÖRNEĞİ
  Ertan TOY, Bahadır UÇAN, Muhemmet Fatih KILAVUZ, Tuba UĞRAŞ, Oğuz ALTUN, Betül AYDOĞDU, Elif ÇALIŞKAN
  Uludağ Üniversitesi Fen-Edebiyat Fakültesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi.2023; 24(45): 539.     CrossRef
• Tourism in the digital frontier: a study on user continuance intention in the metaverse
  Hyeon Jo
  Information Technology & Tourism.2023; 25(3): 307.     CrossRef
• A metaworld: Implications, opportunities and risks of the metaverse
  Fabio De Felice, Mizna Rehman, Antonella Petrillo, Ilaria Baffo
  IET Collaborative Intelligent Manufacturing.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• METAVERSE-BASED ONLINE ENGLISH TEACHING SCHEME IN MULTI-SOURCE AND CROSS-DOMAIN ENVIRONMENT
  ZHIGAO WEI
  Fractals.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Urology: a trip into metaverse
  Gianmarco Randazzo, Giuseppe Reitano, Filippo Carletti, Massimo Iafrate, Giovanni Betto, Giacomo Novara, Fabrizio Dal Moro, Fabio Zattoni
  World Journal of Urology.2023; 41(10): 2647.     CrossRef
• Metaverse ve Eğitim: Yeni Bir Dönem Başlıyor!
  Pelin YILDIRIM, Gonca KEÇECİ
  Milli Eğitim Dergisi.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• A Study on the Future Prospect of the Metaverse through Human Cognition
  SeongJeong Yoon, SooIn Choi
  The Journal of Korean Institute of Information Technology.2023; 21(7): 149.     CrossRef
• An EAACI review: Go green in health care and research. Practical suggestions for sustainability in clinical practice, laboratories, and scientific meetings
  Isabella Pali‐Schöll, Kerstin Hermuth‐Kleinschmidt, Stephanie Dramburg, Ioana Agache, Hanna Mayerhofer, Erika Jensen‐Jarolim, Anna Goshua, Kari C. Nadeau
  Allergy.2023; 78(10): 2606.     CrossRef
• Development of a Core Set of Quality Criteria for Virtual Reality Applications Designed for Older Adults: Multistep Qualitative Study
  Alina Napetschnig, Klara Brixius, Wolfgang Deiters
  Interactive Journal of Medical Research.2023; 12: e45433.     CrossRef
• Metaverse in business research: a systematic literature review
  Egi Arvian Firmansyah, Umar Habibu Umar
  Cogent Business & Management.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Potential to use metaverse for future teaching and learning
  Peter Onu, Anup Pradhan, Charles Mbohwa
  Education and Information Technologies.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• The Metaverse in Industry 5.0: A Human-Centric Approach towards Personalized Value Creation
  Dimitris Mourtzis
  Encyclopedia.2023; 3(3): 1105.     CrossRef
• Platformization and the Metaverse: Opportunities and Challenges for Urban Sustainability and Economic Development
  Aram Mohammed-Amin Qadir, Ava Omar Fatah
  EAI Endorsed Transactions on Energy Web.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Counseling Psychological Understanding and Considerations of the Metaverse: A Theoretical Review
  Kunho Lee
  Healthcare.2023; 11(18): 2490.     CrossRef
• Interactive Virtual Reality with Educational Feedback Loops to Train and Assess Veterinary Students on the Use of Anesthetic Machine
  Lynn Keets, Pedro Boscan, Logan Arakaki, Benjamin Schraeder, Cyane Tornatzky, Marie Vans, Wenjing Jiang, Sangeeta Rao
  Journal of Veterinary Medical Education.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Development of a Metaverse Online Learning System for Undergraduate Nursing Students
  Hyeongju Ryu, Hyeongsuk Lee, Hye Jin Yoo
  Nurse Educator.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• A review of the literature on the metaverse: definition, technologies, and user behaviors
  Zhongyun Zhou, Zidie Chen, Xiao-Ling Jin
  Internet Research.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• 具身博物馆: 虚拟技术视域下的博物馆具身化转向
  Wupeng Zhou
  Curator: The Museum Journal.2023; 66(4): 699.     CrossRef
• Understanding experiences in metaverse: How virtual nature impacts affect, pro-environmental attitudes, and intention to engage with physical nature
  Sarah Hian May Chan, Lin Qiu, Tian Xie
  Computers in Human Behavior.2023; 149: 107926.     CrossRef
• Enhancing STEM Education through Interactive Metaverses: A Case Study and Methodological Framework
  J. Ernesto Solanes, Sergi Montava-Jordà, Emilio Golf-Laville, Vicente Colomer-Romero, Luis Gracia, Adolfo Muñoz
  Applied Sciences.2023; 13(19): 10785.     CrossRef
• The Multidomain Metaverse Cancer Care Digital Platform: Development and Usability Study
  Sunghak Kim, Timothy Jung, Dae Kyung Sohn, Yoon Chae, Young Ae Kim, Seung Hyun Kang, Yujin Park, Yoon Jung Chang
  JMIR Serious Games.2023; 11: e46242.     CrossRef
• Exploring the potential use of the metaverse in nurse education through a mock trial
  Hanyi Lee, Yeojin Yi, Woojong Moon, Ji-Young Yeo
  Nurse Education Today.2023; 131: 105974.     CrossRef
• Frequency-Dependent Reduction of Cybersickness in Virtual Reality by Transcranial Oscillatory Stimulation of the Vestibular Cortex
  Alberto Benelli, Francesco Neri, Alessandra Cinti, Patrizio Pasqualetti, Sara M. Romanella, Alessandro Giannotta, David De Monte, Marco Mandalà, Carmelo Smeralda, Domenico Prattichizzo, Emiliano Santarnecchi, Simone Rossi
  Neurotherapeutics.2023; 20(6): 1796.     CrossRef
• Tutoring in the metaverse. Study on student-teachers’ and tutors’ perceptions about NPC tutor
  Laura Sara Agrati
  Frontiers in Education.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Reaching new heights: investigating adoption factors shaping the moon landing of metaverse tourism
  Rajat Kumar Behera, Pradip Kumar Bala, Nripendra P. Rana
  Information Technology & Tourism.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• The Contributions of Metaverse Technology on Management Information Systems in Strategic Planning and Decision-Making Processes of Businesses
  Vildan BAYRAM, Mustafa KAYA
  Uluslararası Yönetim Akademisi Dergisi.2023; 6(3): 794.     CrossRef
• Unlocking the Potential: A Comprehensive Evaluation of Augmented Reality and Virtual Reality in Education
  Mohammed A. M. AlGerafi, Yueliang Zhou, Mohamed Oubibi, Tommy Tanu Wijaya
  Electronics.2023; 12(18): 3953.     CrossRef
• Effects of Blended Learning on Pharmacy Student Learning Satisfaction and Learning Platform Preferences in a Team-based Learning Pharmacy Experiential Course: A Pilot Study
  So Won Kim, Eun Joo Choi, Yun Jeong Lee
  Korean Journal of Clinical Pharmacy.2023; 33(3): 202.     CrossRef
• Metaverse Key Requirements and Platforms Survey
  Akbobek Abilkaiyrkyzy, Ahmed Elhagry, Fedwa Laamarti, Abdulmotaleb El Saddik
  IEEE Access.2023; 11: 117765.     CrossRef
• La terza dimensione dell’e-learning: il metaverso
  Annamaria Cacchione
  IUL Research.2023; 4(7): 108.     CrossRef
• The metaverse through the lens of public big data analytics: a social perspective
  Enrique Cano-Marin, Cristina Blanco-Gonzalez-Tejero, Domingo Ribeiro-Soriano, Varsha Arya
  Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Human values and traveler behaviors: metaverse for conferences and meetings
  Antonio Ariza-Montes, Wei Quan, Aleksandar Radic, Jongsik Yu, Heesup Han
  Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing.2023; 40(6): 490.     CrossRef
• Phenomenological toolkit of the metaverse for medical informatics’ adaptive learning
  Inna Kryvenko, Kyrylo Chalyy
  Educación Médica.2023; 24(5): 100854.     CrossRef
• METAVERSE AND HEALTHCARE SECTOR
  Ziya ÇEÇEN, Oğuzhan YÜKSEL
  International Journal of Engineering and Innovative Research.2023; 5(3): 280.     CrossRef
• Metaverse in Dermatology Speciality Advancement: Future to Embrace
  Anant Patil, Jacek C. Szepietowski, Mohamad Goldust
  Dermatology.2023; : 1.     CrossRef
• METAVERSE VE İŞLETMELER: MEVCUT UYGULAMALAR-GELECEK SENARYOLARI
  Şayan BERBER
  Anadolu Üniversitesi İktisadi ve İdari Bilimler Fakültesi Dergisi.2023; 24(3): 598.     CrossRef
• Comparing counseling outcome for college students: Metaverse and in-person approaches
  Soohyun cho, Jieun Kang, Woo Hyun Baek, Yeon Bin Jeong, Seongchan Lee, Sang Min Lee
  Psychotherapy Research.2023; : 1.     CrossRef
• Metaverse for tourists and tourism destinations
  Stelios Ioannidis, Alexios-Patapios Kontis
  Information Technology & Tourism.2023; 25(4): 483.     CrossRef
• De-contextual communication: Factors influencing usage intentions of metaverse technology in digital library services
  Sri Sediyaningsih, Mohammad Pandu Ristiyono, Kani Launggu, Peter Ochieng Juma
  Heliyon.2023; 9(10): e20388.     CrossRef
• What will the education of the future look like? How have Metaverse and Extended Reality affected the higher education systems?
  Agnieszka Pregowska, Magdalena Osial, Aleksandra Gajda
  Metaverse Basic and Applied Research.2023; 3: 57.     CrossRef
• Defining the Metaverse with challenges and opportunities in the business environment
  Roberto Bruni, Michela Piccarozzi, Federica Caboni
  Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice.2023; : 1.     CrossRef
• Addressing Body Image Disturbance through Metaverse-Related Technologies: A Systematic Review
  Moises Perez, Adriana Pineda-Rafols, Maria Pilar Egea-Romero, Maria Gonzalez-Moreno, Esther Rincon
  Electronics.2023; 12(22): 4580.     CrossRef
• Metaversity: Beyond Emerging Educational Technology
  Luis Alberto Laurens-Arredondo, Lilibeth Laurens
  Sustainability.2023; 15(22): 15844.     CrossRef
• Perceptions and use of metaverse in higher education: A descriptive study in China and Spain
  Yinglong Qiu, Rosa Isusi-Fagoaga, Adela García-Aracil
  Computers and Education: Artificial Intelligence.2023; 5: 100185.     CrossRef
• Metaverse and oral and maxillofacial radiology: Where do they meet?
  Thaísa Pinheiro Silva, Maria Fernanda Andrade-Bortoletto, Deborah Queiroz Freitas, Christiano Oliveira-Santos, Wilton Mitsunari Takeshita
  European Journal of Radiology.2023; : 111210.     CrossRef
• Twelve tips for teaching in virtual reality
  Pedro Elston, Gian Paulo Canale, Geetika Ail, Nick Fisher, Mythili Mahendran
  Medical Teacher.2023; : 1.     CrossRef
• Accountability and the metaverse: unaccounted digital worlds between techwashing mechanisms and new emerging meanings
  Maurizio Massaro, Rosanna Spanò, Sanjaya Chinthana Kuruppu
  Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Exploring the Potential of Immersive Virtual Reality in Italian Schools: A Practical Workshop with High School Teachers
  Marco Romano, Alessandro Frolli, Alessandro Aloisio, Claudio Russello, Angelo Rega, Francesco Cerciello, Fabio Bisogni
  Multimodal Technologies and Interaction.2023; 7(12): 111.     CrossRef
• Application of computer-based testing in the Korean Medical Licensing Examination, the emergence of the metaverse in medical education, journal metrics and statistics, and appreciation to reviewers and volunteers
  Sun Huh
  Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions.2022; 19: 2.     CrossRef
• The Metaverse—An Alternative Education Space
  Sharon Mistretta
  AI, Computer Science and Robotics Technology.2022; 2022: 1.     CrossRef
• The Metaverse in Cardiovascular Medicine: Applications, Challenges, and the Role of Non-Fungible Tokens
  Ioannis Skalidis, Olivier Muller, Stephane Fournier
  Canadian Journal of Cardiology.2022; 38(9): 1467.     CrossRef
• UTAUT in Metaverse: An “Ifland” Case
  Un-Kon Lee, Hyekyung Kim
  Journal of Theoretical and Applied Electronic Commerce Research.2022; 17(2): 613.     CrossRef
• Sağlık Hizmetlerinin Geleceğinde Metaverse Ekosistemi ve Teknolojileri: Uygulamalar, Fırsatlar ve Zorluklar
  Faruk YILMAZ, Anı Hande METE, Buse FİDAN TÜRKÖN, Özgür İNCE
  Eurasian Journal of Health Technology Assessment.2022; 6(1): 12.     CrossRef
• Role of Technology in Medical Education: SWOC Analysis
  Shruti Jha
  SBV Journal of Basic, Clinical and Applied Health Science.2022; 5(1): 19.     CrossRef
• Definition, roles, and potential research issues of the metaverse in education: An artificial intelligence perspective
  Gwo-Jen Hwang, Shu-Yun Chien
  Computers and Education: Artificial Intelligence.2022; 3: 100082.     CrossRef
• EĞİTİM BAĞLAMINDA METAVERSE
  Ahmet GÖÇEN
  Uluslararası Batı Karadeniz Sosyal ve Beşeri Bilimler Dergisi.2022; 6(1): 98.     CrossRef
• METAVERSE VE SAĞLIK HİZMETLERİ ÜZERİNE BİR DEĞERLENDİRME
  Ferhat Onur AĞAOĞLU, Lokman Onur EKİNCİ, Nurperihan TOSUN
  Erzincan Binali Yıldırım Üniversitesi İktisadi ve İdari Bilimler Fakültesi Dergisi.2022; 4(1): 95.     CrossRef
• Is Metaverse in education a blessing or a curse: a combined content and bibliometric analysis
  Ahmed Tlili, Ronghuai Huang, Boulus Shehata, Dejian Liu, Jialu Zhao, Ahmed Hosny Saleh Metwally, Huanhuan Wang, Mouna Denden, Aras Bozkurt, Lik-Hang Lee, Dogus Beyoglu, Fahriye Altinay, Ramesh C. Sharma, Zehra Altinay, Zhisheng Li, Jiahao Liu, Faizan Ahma
  Smart Learning Environments.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• The Metaverse as a Virtual Form of Smart Cities: Opportunities and Challenges for Environmental, Economic, and Social Sustainability in Urban Futures
  Zaheer Allam, Ayyoob Sharifi, Simon Elias Bibri, David Sydney Jones, John Krogstie
  Smart Cities.2022; 5(3): 771.     CrossRef
• Metaverse phenomenon and its impact on health: A scoping review
  Ali Garavand, Nasim Aslani
  Informatics in Medicine Unlocked.2022; 32: 101029.     CrossRef
• A novel brain-controlled wheelchair combined with computer vision and augmented reality
  Kaixuan Liu, Yang Yu, Yadong Liu, Jingsheng Tang, Xinbin Liang, Xingxing Chu, Zongtan Zhou
  BioMedical Engineering OnLine.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• The Effectiveness of Serious Games in Improving Memory Among Older Adults With Cognitive Impairment: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
  Alaa Abd-alrazaq, Dari Alhuwail, Eiman Al-Jafar, Arfan Ahmed, Farag Shuweihdi, Shuja Mohd Reagu, Mowafa Househ
  JMIR Serious Games.2022; 10(3): e35202.     CrossRef
• Evolution of Medical Conferences for Congenital Heart Disease Imagers in the Era of COVID-19: From Onsite to Virtual Meetings
  I-Chen Tsai, Hyun Woo Goo, Haifa Abdul Latiff, Seon Young Goo, Sang Joon Park
  Cardiovascular Imaging Asia.2022; 6(3): 82.     CrossRef
• Future era of techno-economic analysis: Insights from review
  Slyvester Yew Wang Chai, Frederick Jit Fook Phang, Lip Siang Yeo, Lock Hei Ngu, Bing Shen How
  Frontiers in Sustainability.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Gastroenterology in the Metaverse: The dawn of a new era?
  Chi Zhang, Shuyan Feng, Ruonan He, Yi Fang, Shuo Zhang
  Frontiers in Medicine.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Into the Metaverse – Perspectives on a New Reality
  Tariq Rahaman
  Medical Reference Services Quarterly.2022; 41(3): 330.     CrossRef
• Factors Affecting Learners’ Adoption of an Educational Metaverse Platform: An Empirical Study Based on an Extended UTAUT Model
  Zhuoqi Teng, Yan Cai, Yu Gao, Xiying Zhang, Xinlong Li, Jungmin Shin
  Mobile Information Systems.2022; 2022: 1.     CrossRef
• Virtual reality techniques for trauma education
  Micha Holla, Maarten van den Berg
  Injury.2022; 53: S64.     CrossRef
• The Metaverse: A New Challenge for the Healthcare System: A Scoping Review
  Luca Petrigna, Giuseppe Musumeci
  Journal of Functional Morphology and Kinesiology.2022; 7(3): 63.     CrossRef
• A Study on Analyzing Teachers' Perception and Needs of Using Metaverse in Elementary Online Learning Environment
  Hyeongjong Han, Sumin Hong
  Journal of Digital Contents Society.2022; 23(8): 1383.     CrossRef
• Athlete experiences of communication strategies in applied sports nutrition and future considerations for mobile app supportive solutions
  David Mark Dunne, Carmen Lefevre-Lewis, Brian Cunniffe, Samuel George Impey, David Tod, Graeme Leonard Close, James P. Morton, Rebecca Murphy
  Frontiers in Sports and Active Living.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Metaverse Dünyasının Eğitim Modeli Olarak Kullanımı ve Muhasebe Eğitimine Yansımaları
  Işık ALTUNAL
  Selçuk Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Meslek Yüksekokulu Dergisi.2022; 25(Özel Sayı): 433.     CrossRef
• Exploration of Educational Possibilities by Four Metaverse Types in Physical Education
  Ji-Eun Yu
  Technologies.2022; 10(5): 104.     CrossRef
• The metaverse in education: Definition, framework, features, potential applications, challenges, and future research topics
  Xinli Zhang, Yuchen Chen, Lailin Hu, Youmei Wang
  Frontiers in Psychology.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• The adoption of the metaverse concepts in Romania
  Cătălina Chinie, Marian Oancea, Steluta Todea
  Management & Marketing. Challenges for the Knowledge Society.2022; 17(3): 328.     CrossRef
• Exploring the application scenarios and issues facing Metaverse technology in education
  Zhisheng Chen
  Interactive Learning Environments.2022; : 1.     CrossRef
• Public interest in the digital transformation accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic and perception of its future impact
  Joo-Young Park, Kangsun Lee, Doo Ryeon Chung
  The Korean Journal of Internal Medicine.2022; 37(6): 1223.     CrossRef
• The Arrival of the Metaverse in Neurorehabilitation: Fact, Fake or Vision?
  Rocco Salvatore Calabrò, Antonio Cerasa, Irene Ciancarelli, Loris Pignolo, Paolo Tonin, Marco Iosa, Giovanni Morone
  Biomedicines.2022; 10(10): 2602.     CrossRef
• The paradigm and future value of the metaverse for the intervention of cognitive decline
  Hao Zhou, Jian-Yi Gao, Ying Chen
  Frontiers in Public Health.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Novel pathway regarding good cosmetics brands by NFT in the metaverse world
  Jinkyung Lee, Ki Han Kwon
  Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology.2022; 21(12): 6584.     CrossRef
• The significant transformation of life into health and beauty in metaverse era
  Jinkyung Lee, Ki Han Kwon
  Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology.2022; 21(12): 6575.     CrossRef
• Advances in Metaverse Investigation: Streams of Research and Future Agenda
  Mariapina Trunfio, Simona Rossi
  Virtual Worlds.2022; 1(2): 103.     CrossRef
• Dynamics of Metaverse and Medicine: A Review Article
  Mrudul A Kawarase, Ashish Anjankar
  Cureus.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• METAVERSE TOPLUMU: KİMLİK, MEKÂN VE YENİ TOPLULUK BİLİNCİ
  Filiz GÜVEN, İlkim GÜVEN
  Erciyes Akademi.2022; 36(4): 1792.     CrossRef
• Empirical Research on the Metaverse User Experience of Digital Natives
  Han Jin Lee, Hyun Hee Gu
  Sustainability.2022; 14(22): 14747.     CrossRef
• When Digital Economy Meets Web3.0: Applications and Challenges
  Chuan Chen, Lei Zhang, Yihao Li, Tianchi Liao, Siran Zhao, Zibin Zheng, Huawei Huang, Jiajing Wu
  IEEE Open Journal of the Computer Society.2022; 3: 233.     CrossRef
• Metaverse as Future Promising Platform Business Model: Case Study on Fashion Value Chain
  Saravanan Periyasami, Aravin Prince Periyasamy
  Businesses.2022; 2(4): 527.     CrossRef
• Into the RetinaVerse: A New Frontier of Retina in the Metaverse
  Joshua Ong, Seenu M. Hariprasad, Jay Chhablani
  Ophthalmic Surgery, Lasers and Imaging Retina.2022; 53(11): 595.     CrossRef
• Metaverse and education: the pioneering case of Minecraft in immersive digital learning
  Iván Sánchez-López, Rosabel Roig-Vila, Amor Pérez-Rodríguez
  El Profesional de la información.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Sustainable and Safe Consumer Experience NFTs and Raffles in the Cosmetics Market after COVID-19
  Jinkyung Lee, Ki Han Kwon
  Sustainability.2022; 14(23): 15718.     CrossRef
• Metaverso: el futuro de la medicina en un mundo virtual
  Carlos Miguel Campos Sánchez, Laura Adalys Guillén León, Rossio Cristina Acosta Yanes, Marcos Antonio Gil Oloriz
  Metaverse Basic and Applied Research.2022; 1: 4.     CrossRef
• A Review of Metaverse’s Definitions, Architecture, Applications, Challenges, Issues, Solutions, and Future Trends
  Abbas M. Al-Ghaili, Hairoladenan Kasim, Naif Mohammed Al-Hada, Zainuddin Bin Hassan, Marini Othman, Jakir Hussain Tharik, Rafiziana Md. Kasmani, Ibraheem Shayea
  IEEE Access.2022; 10: 125835.     CrossRef
• Using Cinematic Virtual Reality to Get Acquainted with the Metaverse
  Ermo Säks
  Baltic Screen Media Review.2022; 10(2): 252.     CrossRef
• A study of factors influencing Chinese college students’ intention of using metaverse technology for basketball learning: Extending the technology acceptance model
  Longfei Ren, Fangfang Yang, Chao Gu, Jie Sun, Yunfeng Liu
  Frontiers in Psychology.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Touch IoT enabled by wireless self-sensing and haptic-reproducing electronic skin
  Dengfeng Li, Jingkun Zhou, Kuanming Yao, Sitong Liu, Jiahui He, Jingyou Su, Qing’ao Qu, Yuyu Gao, Zhen Song, Chunki Yiu, Chuanlu Sha, Zhi Sun, Binbin Zhang, Jian Li, Libei Huang, Chenyu Xu, Tsz Hung Wong, Xingcan Huang, Jiyu Li, Ruquan Ye, Lei Wei, Zhengy
  Science Advances.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• What the Literature on Medicine, Nursing, Public Health, Midwifery, and Dentistry Reveals: An Overview of the Rapidly Approaching Metaverse
  Muhammet DAMAR
  Journal of Metaverse.2022; 2(2): 62.     CrossRef
• REFLECTION OF VIRTUAL REALITY ON ACCOUNTING EDUCATION: TRANSFORMATION OF UNIVERSITY TO METAVERSITY
  Şebnem YAŞAR
  Journal of Business in The Digital Age.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
• Influencing Factors of Usage Intention of Metaverse Education Application Platform: Empirical Evidence Based on PPM and TAM Models
  Gaofeng Wang, Changhoon Shin
  Sustainability.2022; 14(24): 17037.     CrossRef
• El futuro de la salud en el metaverso
  Lee Yang Díaz-Chieng, Jhossmar Cristians Auza-Santiváñez, Jose Ignacio Robaina Castillo
  Metaverse Basic and Applied Research.2022; 1: 1.     CrossRef
• Is online objective structured clinical examination teaching an acceptable replacement in post-COVID-19 medical education in the United Kingdom?: a descriptive study
  Vashist Motkur, Aniket Bharadwaj, Nimalesh Yogarajah
  Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions.2022; 19: 30.     CrossRef
• What Is Metaverse?—A Definition Based on Qualitative Meta-Synthesis
  Markus Weinberger
  Future Internet.2022; 14(11): 310.     CrossRef
• Interactive and innovative technologies for smart education
  Babatomiwa Omonayajo, Fadi Al-Turjman, Nadire Cavus
  Computer Science and Information Systems.2022; 19(3): 1549.     CrossRef
• A Scoping Review of the Metaverse for Software Engineering Education: Overview, Challenges, and Opportunities
  Filipe A. Fernandes, Cláudia M. L. Werner
  PRESENCE: Virtual and Augmented Reality.2022; 31: 107.     CrossRef
• Training in lung cancer surgery through the metaverse, including extended reality, in the smart operating room of Seoul National University Bundang Hospital, Korea
  Huilyung Koo
  Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions.2021; 18: 33.     CrossRef