Skip Navigation
Skip to contents

JEEHP : Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions

OPEN ACCESS
SEARCH
Search
Advanced Search
mobile menu button

Articles

Page Path
HOME > J Educ Eval Health Prof > Volume 11; 2014 > Article
Research Article
 Reflective writing and its impact on empathy in medical education: systematic review
Isabel Chen1,2orcid, Connor Forbes1*orcid

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3352/jeehp.2014.11.20
Published online: August 16, 2014

1University of British Columbia Faculty of Medicine, Vancouver, Canada

2Yale University, New Haven, CT, USA

*Corresponding email: cmforbes@alumni.ubc.ca

: 

• Received: May 20, 2014   • Accepted: August 15, 2014

© 2014, National Health Personnel Licensing Examination Board of the Republic of Korea

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

prev next
  • 46,949 Views
  • 471 Download
  • 89 Web of Science
  • 77 Crossref
Full Article

Download PDF Download PDF

  • Purpose:
    Medical schools are increasingly aware of the ways in which physician empathy can have a profound impact on patients’ lives and have developed humanities initiatives to address this concern. Reflective writing in particular is more commonly promoted in medical curricula, but there is limited research on the impact of reflective writing on medical student empathy levels. It aims to find the emotional effects of reflective writing interventions on medical and healthcare students by systemic review.
  • Methods:
    Two investigators independently reviewed educational publications for critical analysis. This review focused systematically on quantitative papers that measure the impact of reflective writing on empathy.
  • Results:
    Of the 1,032 studies found on Medline and CINAHL, only 8 used quantitative measures pre- and postwritten reflection to measure any impact on empathy outcomes. The outcomes measured included impact of reflective writing exercises on student wellness, aptitude, and/or clinical skills. Of these studies, a significant change in student empathy was observed in 100% of the studies, demonstrating a significant change in outcomes.
  • Conclusion:
    Although the lack of homogeneity in outcome measurement in the literature limits possible conclusion from this review, the overwhelmingly positive reporting of outcomes suggests that reflective writing should be considered in any medical curriculum.
  • Keywords: Aptitude; Clinical competence; Empathy; Medical students; Writing
Medical education trains students to become clinicians with strong technical and interpersonal skills that significantly impact patient outcomes. Research shows that stress in medical practice leads to clinician burnout and a loss of physician empathy, lower quality patient care, patient dissatisfaction, and increased medical errors and malpractice [1-4]. These declines in mood and attitude begin even as early as the third year of medical training [5]. Previous reviews have addressed the importance of reflective practice in the curriculum [6] and have looked at the effects of various methods of reflection as teaching tools in medical education, including literature courses and communication workshops [7,8]. In response to these findings, reflective practice is receiving increasing focus in medical schools across Canada and the United States due in part to the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) and CanMeds competencies [9]. Yet there is a lack of convincing evidence in the literature [8]. One author lamented in a review on reflection that “the literature is replete with accounts of the possible benefits to practitioners and clients of using reflection in practice, yet this amounts to a rather scant evidence base” [10].
Previous papers classified as reviews on the topic of reflective writing in medical education exist [11,12], but do not exclusively review papers with quantitative outcomes. The potential for reflective writing to improve exam scores, clinical skills and diagnostic accuracy have been shown in recent studies [13,14]. These important clinical improvements may occur in addition to the touted potential to broaden students’ intellectual and emotional horizons [15]. Many of the studies reviewed, however, are not structured as reproducible given their design. To our knowledge, there are no currently existing systematic reviews of the literature on the emotional effects of reflective writing interventions on medical and healthcare students. This paper will address this deficit.
Criteria for studies in this review
Types of studies are conference proceedings, abstracts, and full papers. Types of participants are students in all health occupations (dental, medical, nursing, pharmacy, and premedical). Types of interventions are interventions of interest were reflective and written (including journaling, diaries, blogs, and reports). Other forms of reflection such as art and music were excluded.
Types of outcome measures (1) primary outcome was a change in student wellness, aptitude and/or clinical skills; (2) secondary outcome was identification of strengths and weaknesses of various reflective writing interventions.
Study methods

Search strategy

A comprehensive systematic search was conducted in Medline and Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL). The electronic search included all English-language articles published until January 22, 2013. We did not include empathy-related terms in the search because doing so eliminated a body of articles that described the effect of reflective writing with different language.
Medline was searched using OvidSP interface on 22 January, 2013, for the period 1,949 to the week of 21 January, 2013. We searched for any reflective work-including written journals, reports or diaries-performed by students in health occupations. CINAHL was searched using EBSCOHost interface on 22 January, 2013, for the period 1982 to the week of 21 January, 2013. The search terms, similarly, included any reflection or reflective work performed by students in health occupations.

Study selection

Two reviewers (CF and IC) independently assessed all search results using inclusion criteria. The first round of screening was to exclude: strictly qualitative abstracts from non-health professional fields, articles without a written reflective component as opposed to other forms (drawing, music, etc.), absence of pre- or post-intervention measures. Articles without control groups were not excluded in this round. In our second round of screening, the remaining mixed methods papers were critiqued based on international collaborative guides for analyzing medical education interventions [16]. Each article’s question, rationale, objectives, study design, intervention, evaluation, and results were appraised. Outcomes of interest included quantifiable impact or efficacy of reflective writing exercises on student wellness, aptitude and/or clinical skills.

Data selection and management

Both investigators independently reviewed all search results from both rounds. After completion of the second round of screening, all accepted studies were combined and re-assessed by each reviewer for adherence to criteria. All articles that met inclusion criteria according to both reviewers were included in the final analysis. Key data extracted from each article was based on the criteria by Reed et al. [16]. The manuscript was checked according to preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (PRISMA) and all topics were fulfilled.

Statistical analysis

Summary statistics were calculated for common study characteristics and features.
Our search revealed 706 papers from Medline and 326 papers from CINAHL, totaling 1,032. The abstract analysis of all papers yielded 53 papers that were thought to meet inclusion criteria. Full manuscript review narrowed this to 8 final papers that quantified changes in empathy and patient interaction skills following an intervention that involved reflective writing. The eight papers that met final inclusion criteria are summarized in Tables 1 and 2. Of note, seven of these papers describe interventions in the United States, while 1 took place in Sweden. No studies of the Canadian population met inclusion criteria. The papers all staged interventions in students in the allied healthcare professions: four of the papers targeted medical students and the other four targeted pharmacy students.
Although all the included papers used reflective writing as an intervention, their approaches to its introduction differed. Two of the studies introduced reflective writing as an isolated update to a previously existing course [17,18]. In three other studies, reflection was one of several components instituted in a course’s renewed curriculum, or in a new course [19-21]. One study boldly randomized students to write monthly essays reflecting on hypothetical encounters in different styles: clinical reasoning or reflective point-of-view [22]. This was the only study in our review to run simultaneous randomized interventions as part of a medical school curriculum; no comment was made by the authors on strategies to enlist administrative leadership to support such important research.
In the analyzed studies, empathy was measured in student self-perception, patient feedback, and third-party observation. Many of the studies also used multiple metrics to strengthen their findings. Two of the papers used previously validated metrics: one for empathy and one for attitudes towards geriatric patients. These were the best objective indicators of the effects of the interventions on empathy. Another two papers used multiple choice exams without external validation focusing on communication skills. Although these papers did not directly measure empathy, it would be expected that communication skills would correlate with students’ investments in and compassionate care for their patients. Four papers looked for outcomes in student writing such as insight in an essay on a patient death, the level of reflection in essays, the cultural sensitivity in an essay, and a holistic evaluation of writing. Each of these directly or indirectly requires insight into the patient’s psyche-a key component of empathy. Finally, one paper measured its outcomes through a survey on satisfaction with the intervention and its effect on the students’ mindset. This self-reporting mechanism was the weakest metric, especially because the study lacked a control group for comparison.
Unfortunately, seven of these eight papers addressed only short-term outcomes of one year or less. The lone paper that examined long-term outcomes also only measured outcomes immediately following the intervention, but it was defined as a long-term outcome since the intervention took place over four years. None of the papers measured empathic changes after any significant latency period. This makes it difficult to accurately gauge profound changes compared to situational, performance-based empathy.
The composition of control groups was inconsistent across the papers. Half of the papers (4/8) used a control group that was composed of different subjects than the intervention group. Of these 4, half again (2/8) used a concurrent comparison group, while the other half (2/8) used a cohort control strategy where the results of a healthcare class after the implementation of a new curriculum change was measured against the results of the previous healthcare class. In the remaining papers, 3/8 (37.5%) used pre- and post-tests to compare the intervention. One study had no control group, which is a serious concern, but the conclusions drawn by this paper were adequately tempered to warrant inclusion in this review. Overall, limitations concerning control groups contributed to the shortcomings in study design that curb the conclusions that can be drawn from this review.
Despite the current popularity of reflective writing in medical education, there is very limited quantitative data that prove its impact on students’ educational experiences, clinical skills or future well-being. From our initial search, we yielded a total of 1,032 studies, of which only 8 fit our inclusion criteria. The data, although limited, did show improvements in students’ levels of empathy and respect for patients [20-23], ability to self-reflect [24], cultural competency [17,19], and communication skills [18].
The review revealed significant inconsistencies in study design. In evidence-based medicine, randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are the gold standard; in medical education, however, few interventions use this study design. Whether this discrepancy is based on inadequate resources, educational philosophy or ethics [25,26], the literature is full of observational studies and quasi-experimental methods [15,27,28]. The studies in this review were all unique reflective writing programs with no reproducible measurable outcome, which makes translation and application of these initiatives difficult. The 8 studies identified were completed at different institutions, limiting the opportunity to measure statistical power and generalizability. This review is limited by marked heterogeneity in study designs, each article applying its own intervention to unique populations with different definitions and measures of empathy. Methodological critique was therefore limited. In order to expand available literature, we did not limit studies to medical students and the data from other health professions may not be directly beneficial to medical students. These limitations make it very difficult to meet the need for evidence-based medical training.
Despite program variability, the review illustrated consistent, positive outcomes of self-reflection on student well-being and clinical skills. It is important to note that several of the papers identified reflective writing as both intervention and metric [24]. The pre- and post-internship reflective essays on patient counselling explored by Wallman et al. [24] is a strong example that showed a statistically significant difference in depth of reflection and empathy. Through the authors’ lens, reflective writing can be seen as both a test that teaches and measures empathy changes. Its use as a self-validating empathetic intervention in particular deserves further exploration.
Physician burnout negatively influences patient care, patient satisfaction, medical errors and malpractice [1-4]. Research has shown that loss of empathy and cynicism begins in the early years of medical training [5], yet none of the studies in this review measured students’ responses from the perspective of patients and patient-care. Short-term improvements were shown in student insight and empathy toward patients [17,19-23], and there is potential for long-term gains with improvements in study design. Finding reliable and effective early interventions in medical education that can mediate loss of compassion and burnout has the potential to profoundly improve health care.
The studies that met all of our inclusion criteria did not universally measure the same traits related to empathy, use the same scales, and/or structure the interventions in similar fashions for similar durations. As such, it is essential that future studies focus in on one or two empathy- or compassion-related signs and limited personal or professional outcomes to avoid measuring empathy as a colossal, complex phenomenon [29]. With all of these limitations in mind, it is still telling that all of the papers (8/8) showed an improvement in students’ empathy through the primary or secondary subset of metrics. All of the papers with multiple choice examinations showed an improvement in student scores in part or all of the examinations, and for those papers whose outcomes were measured with essays the students showed an increase in insight, empathy, or cultural sensitivity. Perhaps most interestingly to medical educators, the survey on student opinion had a majority of positive responses to the change in curriculum. These positive data support an argument for reflective writing in a medical curriculum. A specific methodology has yet to be agreed upon.
Despite the dearth of literature that demonstrates the impact of reflective writing on students’ clinical skills and performance, there is a wealth of studies that illustrate the improvement of student empathy. There is significant room for improvement in designing reflective writing interventions that are consistent with focused empathy outcomes to guide evidence-based medical curriculum. This would improve the quality of writing exercises that are growing in popularity among health professional programs. This research shows that health provider burnout begins early on in medical training and early reflective interventions targeted against compassion-loss can have profound potential on physician well-being and patient outcomes.

No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.

Audio recording of the abstract.
jeehp-11-20-abstract-recording.avi
Table 1.
Study locations, populations, and intervention protocols
Study Country Population studied Intervention protocol
Haack and Phillips, 2012 [19] USA 135 PharmD students Cohort study on a cultural competency course with a renewed curriculum. Group and individual reflection activities following lectures and clinical encounters, including a reflective paper.
Lie et al., 2010 [17] USA 376 Medical students Guided written reflection following clinic encounters, performed in small groups over a 4-week family practice elective.
Lonie and Rahim, 2010 [18] USA 210 Pharmacy students The addition of a reflective writing component to a communication skills course over one semester. This included two short (3–5 page) and one long (6–8 page) reflective papers.
Plake, 2010 [21] USA 20 Pharmacy students Weekly written reflections in a book club focusing on novels describing patients’ experiences with chronic illness.
Roche, 2007 [20] USA 15 Pharmacy students Reflective journals kept following readings and discussions in a Native American service learning elective.
Shapiro et al., 2006 [22] USA 92 Medical students Students randomized to point-of-view reflective writing or clinical reasoning style of writing for monthly essays following simulated patient modules.
Wallman et al., 2008 [24] Sweden 146 Pharmacy students Pre- and post-course reflective essays for a 6 month pharmacy internship experience.
Westmoreland et al., 2009 [23] USA 237 Medical students Pre- and post-reflective writing for meeting sessions with a geriatric population.
Table 2.
Study outcomes and conclusions
Study Outcome(s) measured Result
Haack and Phillips, 2012 [19] Cultural competency through the Inventory to Assess the Process of Cultural Competence-revised (IAPCC-R): a validated self-assessment tool. Overall cultural competency did not differ between intervention and non-intervention groups, but cultural skills and cultural encounters scores were higher for the intervention group.
Lie et al., 2010 [17] An assessment questionnaire to quantify the new course’s relevance in preparing students for a cross-cultural practice; a pre- and post-essay style test on cultural competency. The students’responses were 83% positive for the course, and they showed a statistically significant score improvement on the post-test relative to the pre-test.
Lonie and Rahim, 2010 [18] Objective Structure Clinical Examination (OSCE) scores and multiple choice examinations for a communications course. A statistically significant increase in multiple choice scores was observed in the intervention group, with no change in OSCE scores.
Plake, 2010 [21] After the elective, students completed retrospective surveys (5-point Likert scale) on their perceived functional empathy before and after the course. Students showed statistically significant increases in self-assessed ability to complete empathy and compassion related tasks.
Roche, 2007 [20] A post survey evaluation of course objectives, including empathy-related statements regarding underserved populations. Researchers found significant improvements in students’“cultural appreciation and respect, awareness of health disparities and the need for social responsibility, appreciation for the spiritual aspect of wellness, and the positive impact of traditions on health, and a recognition of professionally rewarding practice opportunities.”
Shapiro et al., 2006 [22] OSCE exams scores were compared. The two groups did not differ on OSCE exam scores, but in the essay point-of-view writers were more likely to adopt the first person, to show empathy for the physician, and showed a higher score in overall empathy and insight.
Wallman et al., 2008 [24] Essays were graded on a rubric of level of reflection with good inter-rater reliability (k5 = 0.63). The levels of reflection scored in the essays pre- and post-course increased significantly.
Westmoreland et al., 2009 [23] Reflective writing was analyzed for themes as a means of assessing changing attitudes and perceptions toward the elderly; a written pre- and post-survey on geriatric attitudes was administered; a learner satisfaction survey was administered. Reflective writing analysis found a change in perception of elderly: 27% of participants changed their negative into positive or reinforced their pre-existing positive attitudes. 98% of students were also satisfied with the learning experience delivered by the sessions and writing exercises.

Figure & Data

References

    Citations

    Citations to this article as recorded by  
    • Impact of reflective writing skill on emotional quotient
      Swapnali S. Kadam, Shilpa K. Kolhe, Vrushali V. Kulkarni, Poorva A. Sule
      Medical Journal Armed Forces India.2024; 80(2): 205.     CrossRef
    • Can storytelling of women’s lived experience enhance empathy in medical students? A pilot intervention study
      Parimala Kanagasabai, Judy Ormandy, Sara Filoche, Claire Henry, Sarah Te Whaiti, Robin Willink, Tehmina Gladman, Rebecca Grainger
      Medical Teacher.2024; 46(2): 219.     CrossRef
    • A narrative analysis of clerkship reflections: Medical student identity development in a changing world
      Mahino A. Talib, Richard E. Greene, Abigail Ford Winkel
      The Clinical Teacher.2024;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • Communication and empathy of nursing students in patient care through telenursing: A comparative cross-sectional study
      Lorena Gutiérrez-Puertas, Vanesa Gutiérrez-Puertas, Blanca Ortiz-Rodríguez, Gabriel Aguilera-Manrique, Verónica V. Márquez-Hernández
      Nurse Education Today.2024; 133: 106048.     CrossRef
    • The integrated curriculum and student empathy: a longitudinal multi-cohort analysis
      Christiane R. Herber-Valdez, Julie A. Blow, Tammy T. Salazar, Kathryn V. Horn, Dyanne G. Herrera, Naomi L. Lacy, Lisa Beinhoff, J. Manuel de la Rosa
      Advances in Health Sciences Education.2024; 29(4): 1131.     CrossRef
    • Promoting health education through collaborative writing sessions in the Dominican Republic
      Helena J Chapman, Bienvenido A Veras-Estévez
      Health Education Journal.2024; 83(1): 95.     CrossRef
    • Exploring medical students’ perceptions of empathy after cinemeducation based on Vygotsky’s theory
      Mahla Salajegheh, Amir Ali Sohrabpour, Elaheh Mohammadi
      BMC Medical Education.2024;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • Reflective capacity and context of reflections: qualitative study of second-year medical students’ learning diaries related to a general practice course
      Elina Paloniemi, Maria Hagnäs, Ilona Mikkola, Markku Timonen, Ritva Vatjus
      BMC Medical Education.2024;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • Use and effectiveness of the arts for enhancing healthcare students' empathy skills: A mixed methods systematic review
      Tracy Levett-Jones, Elizabeth Brogan, Deborah Debono, Mark Goodhew, Natalie Govind, Jacqui Pich, Jo River, Judith Smith, Suzanne Sheppard-Law, Robyn Cant
      Nurse Education Today.2024; 138: 106185.     CrossRef
    • Reflect to interact – fostering medical students’ communication through reflection-focused e-learning
      Laura Janssen, Kristina Schick, Tiziana Neurohr, Sylvia Irene Donata Pittroff, Sabine Reiser, Johannes Bauer, Pascal O. Berberat, Martin Gartmeier
      BMC Medical Education.2024;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • Factors Influencing Primary Care Career Choice: A Multi-Institutional Cross-sectional Survey of Internal Medicine Primary Care Residency Graduates
      Paul O’Rourke, Sean Tackett, Karen Chacko, Stephen J. Knaus, Marc Shalaby, Shelly-Ann Fluker, Mina Ma, Maryann Overland, Scott Wright
      Journal of General Internal Medicine.2024;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • From experience to empathy: An empathetic VR-based learning approach to improving EFL learners’ empathy and writing performance
      Jue-Qi Guan, Shu-Fan Ying, Min-Li Zhang, Gwo-Jen Hwang
      Computers & Education.2024; 220: 105120.     CrossRef
    • Understanding the interrelations between cultural empathy, intercultural communication competence, and the psychosocial adjustment of international students in Canada: A longitudinal examination
      Ying Shan Doris Zhang, Kimberly A. Noels
      International Journal of Intercultural Relations.2024; 102: 102023.     CrossRef
    • Cinemeducation: Using Movie Clips to Enhance Empathy among Medical Interns
      Kranti Tekulapally
      Medical Journal of Dr. D.Y. Patil Vidyapeeth.2024; 17(5): 1043.     CrossRef
    • The effectiveness of Balint groups at improving empathy in medical and nursing education: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
      Bin Gong, Xiaochen Zhang, Chen Lu, Chengcheng Wu, Jin Yang
      BMC Medical Education.2024;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • The association between empathy and artistic practice: a cross-sectional study with medical students
      Martim Fornetti, Miguel Barbosa
      BMC Medical Education.2024;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • Empathy and shame through critical phenomenology: The limits and possibilities of affective work and the case of COVID‐19 vaccinations
      Maryam Golafshani
      Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice.2023; 29(7): 1143.     CrossRef
    • Mind The Gap: A Philosophical Analysis of Reflection’s Many Benefits
      Sven Peter Charlotte Schaepkens, Thijs Lijster
      Teaching and Learning in Medicine.2023; 35(3): 368.     CrossRef
    • Reflection in the training of general practitioners in clinical practice settings: a scoping review protocol
      Linda Schumann Scheel, Niels Kristian Kjaer, Casey Marnie, Micah D.J. Peters
      JBI Evidence Synthesis.2023; 21(7): 1501.     CrossRef
    • Narrative medicine as a teaching strategy for nursing students to developing professionalism, empathy and humanistic caring ability: a randomized controlled trial
      Mengxin Xue, Huiping Sun, Jin Xue, Jingxin Zhou, Junchao Qu, Siqi Ji, Yuan Bu, Yongbing Liu
      BMC Medical Education.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • Influence of Emotional Skills on Attitudes towards Communication: Nursing Students vs. Nurses
      María del Carmen Giménez-Espert, Sandra Maldonado, Vicente Prado-Gascó
      International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2023; 20(6): 4798.     CrossRef
    • A penny for your thoughts: promoting compassionate medical practice through reflection
      Kirsty Brownlie
      Reflective Practice.2023; 24(3): 389.     CrossRef
    • Educational opportunities about ethics and professionalism in the clinical environment: surveys of 3rd year medical students to understand and address elements of the hidden curriculum
      Wayne Shelton, Sara Silberstein, Lisa Campo-Engelstein, Henry Pohl, James Desemone, Liva H. Jacoby
      International Journal of Ethics Education.2023; 8(2): 351.     CrossRef
    • Empathy, emotional intelligence and interprofessional skills in healthcare education
      Jonathan P. McNulty, Yurgos Politis
      Journal of Medical Imaging and Radiation Sciences.2023; 54(2): 238.     CrossRef
    • An undergraduate course on pain: Its impact on students' empathy
      Adriana H. van Houwelingen, Ilayda Özaydin, Theo Wubbels
      Currents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning.2023; 15(6): 559.     CrossRef
    • Activities to promote empathy for patients among pharmacy learners: A scoping review
      Kimberly B. Garza, Adelia Grabowsky, Lindsey E. Moseley, Bradley M. Wright, Brandy R. Davis, Channing R. Ford
      Currents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning.2023; 15(10): 911.     CrossRef
    • Medical Humanities in Undergraduate Psychiatry Teaching: Learner Assessment and Mediators of Better Learning Outcomes
      Arvind Rajagopalan, Qian Hui Chew, Kang Sim
      Journal of Medical Education and Curricular Development.2023;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • Assessment tools for reflection in healthcare learners: A scoping review
      Cassandra Préfontaine, Isabelle Gaboury, Hélène Corriveau, Jacinthe Beauchamp, Chantal Lemire, Marie-Josée April
      Medical Teacher.2022; 44(4): 394.     CrossRef
    • Is reflection like soap? a critical narrative umbrella review of approaches to reflection in medical education research
      Sven P. C. Schaepkens, M. Veen, A. de la Croix
      Advances in Health Sciences Education.2022; 27(2): 537.     CrossRef
    • Impact of social pediatrics rotation on residents’ understanding of social determinants of health
      Kimberly Connors, Marghalara Rashid, Mercedes Chan, Jennifer Walton, Bonnieca Islam
      Medical Education Online.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • Introspective self-narrative modulates the neuronal response during the emphatic process: an event-related potentials (ERPs) study
      Daniela Altavilla, Ines Adornetti, Alessandra Chiera, Valentina Deriu, Alessandro Acciai, Francesco Ferretti
      Experimental Brain Research.2022;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • Supporting Resident Wellness Through Reflection on Professional Identity
      Diana Toubassi, Milena Forte, Lindsay Herzog, Michael Roberts, Carly Schenker, Ian Waters, Erin Bearss
      Education in the Health Professions.2022; 5(3): 85.     CrossRef
    • Can doctors be taught virtue?
      Ariel Lefkowitz, Dafna Meitar, Ayelet Kuper
      Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice.2021; 27(3): 543.     CrossRef
    • Sustainable Engaged Accountable Learners
      Michael A. Gisondi, Jeremy Branzetti, Laura R. Hopson, Linda Regan, Wendy C. Coates
      AEM Education and Training.2021;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • Reflective Writing on the Cadaveric Dissection Experience: An Effective Tool to Assess the Impact of Dissection on Learning of Anatomy, Humanism, Empathy, Well‐Being, and Professional Identity Formation in Medical Students
      Matthew P. Abrams, Tabitha Eckert, Daniel Topping, Katherine D. Daly
      Anatomical Sciences Education.2021; 14(5): 658.     CrossRef
    • Bringing narratives from physicians, patients and caregivers together: a scoping review of published research
      Tracy Moniz, John Costella, Maryam Golafshani, Chris Watling, Lorelei Lingard
      Medical Humanities.2021; 47(1): 27.     CrossRef
    • Effectiveness of simulation-based interventions at improving empathy among healthcare students: A systematic review and meta-analysis
      Joelle Yan Xin Chua, Emily Ang, Siew Tiang Lydia Lau, Shefaly Shorey
      Nurse Education Today.2021; 104: 105000.     CrossRef
    • Medical Students’ Creation of Original Poetry, Comics, and Masks to Explore Professional Identity Formation
      Johanna Shapiro, Juliet McMullin, Gabriella Miotto, Tan Nguyen, Anju Hurria, Minh Anh Nguyen
      Journal of Medical Humanities.2021; 42(4): 603.     CrossRef
    • Incorporating reflective writing into criminal justice courses
      Amie R. Scheidegger
      Reflective Practice.2020; 21(1): 122.     CrossRef
    • Why Write?
      Laura Weiss Roberts, John Coverdale
      Academic Medicine.2020; 95(2): 169.     CrossRef
    • A Comparison of Guided Video Reflection versus Self-Regulated Learning to Teach Knot Tying to Medical Students: A Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial
      Peter Zhan Tao Wang, Wen Yan Xie, Shiva Nair, Sumit Dave, John Shatzer, Saad Chahine
      Journal of Surgical Education.2020; 77(4): 805.     CrossRef
    • Empathy training in health sciences: A systematic review
      Pilar Bas-Sarmiento, Martina Fernández-Gutiérrez, María Baena-Baños, Alba Correro-Bermejo, Pablo Sergio Soler-Martins, Sonia de la Torre-Moyano
      Nurse Education in Practice.2020; 44: 102739.     CrossRef
    • Reflections of an Integrated Maternal-Child Health Medical Student Assignment
      Christopher J. McCauley, J. Alex Miles, Benjamin W. Frush, Gary L. Beck Dallaghan, Sofia Aliaga, Maria Ferris, Richard Hobbs
      Maternal and Child Health Journal.2020; 24(6): 679.     CrossRef
    • Content and outcomes of narrative medicine programmes: a systematic review of the literature through 2019
      Christy DiFrances Remein, Ellen Childs, John Carlo Pasco, Ludovic Trinquart, David B Flynn, Sarah L Wingerter, Robina M Bhasin, Lindsay B Demers, Emelia J Benjamin
      BMJ Open.2020; 10(1): e031568.     CrossRef
    • Interpersonal communication, empathy, and stress perceived by nursing students who use social networks
      Lorena Gutiérrez‐Puertas, Verónica V. Márquez‐Hernández, Vanesa Gutiérrez‐Puertas, Genoveva Granados‐Gámez, Gabriel Aguilera‐Manrique
      Journal of Advanced Nursing.2020; 76(10): 2610.     CrossRef
    • Response to: an exploratory cross-sectional study on the relationship between dispositional mindfulness and empathy in undergraduate medical students
      Sithhipratha Arulrajan, Nazifa Ullah, Pranavan Pavanerathan
      Medical Education Online.2020;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • The Impact of Meeting Patients with Neurological Disorders on Medical Student Empathy
      Catherine Eve Tisdale, Asa C. Black, Sandip Jain, Ervin Lowther, Lee Madeline, Chris Troup, Thomas Nathaniel, L. A. Fowler
      Medical Science Educator.2020; 30(4): 1561.     CrossRef
    • Added value of assessing medical students’ reflective writings in communication skills training: a longitudinal study in four academic centres
      Camila Ament Giuliani Franco, Renato Soleiman Franco, Dario Cecilio-Fernandes, Milton Severo, Maria Amélia Ferreira, Marco Antonio de Carvalho-Filho
      BMJ Open.2020; 10(11): e038898.     CrossRef
    • Reflective writing: Implementation and learning perception from students and teachers of French nursing schools
      Tony Timizar-Le Pen, Claire Marchand, Marie Léocadie, Monique Rothan-Tondeur
      Nurse Education in Practice.2020; 49: 102921.     CrossRef
    • Innovative Communication Learning: Combining TED Talks and Reflective Writing for Nursing Students
      Maureen Hillier, Donna Luff, Elaine C. Meyer
      Creative Nursing.2020; 26(3): 182.     CrossRef
    • A Four-Week Reflective Writing Program in the Psychiatry Clerkship: Testing Effects on Reflective Capacity
      Charles A. Whitmore, Joseph Sakai, Susan K. Mikulich-Gilbertson, Robert D. Davies
      Academic Psychiatry.2019; 43(2): 171.     CrossRef
    • Reflective Practices Among Global Health Fellows in the HEAL Initiative: a Qualitative Study
      Zachary G. Jacobs, Robin Tittle, Joseph Scarpelli, Karen Cortez, Samuel D. Aptekar, Sriram Shamasunder
      Journal of General Internal Medicine.2019; 34(4): 521.     CrossRef
    • Empathy assessment in healthcare students is highly heterogeneous: A systematic review and meta-analysis (2012-2016)
      Konstantinos C Fragkos, Ioannis Sotiropoulos, Christos C Frangos
      World Journal of Meta-Analysis.2019; 7(1): 1.     CrossRef
    • Practical Tips for Implementing a Student-Led Reflective Writing Workshop Series
      Andi Shahu, Alyssa R. Thomas, Eli Neustadter, Anna Reisman
      Medical Science Educator.2019; 29(3): 863.     CrossRef
    • Teaching empathy to nursing students: A randomised controlled trial
      Pilar Bas-Sarmiento, Martina Fernández-Gutiérrez, Mercedes Díaz-Rodríguez, Concepción Carnicer-Fuentes, Cristina Castro-Yuste, María José García-Cabanillas, Cristina Gavira-Fernández, María de los Ángeles Martelo-Baro, Olga Paloma-Castro, María del Carmen
      Nurse Education Today.2019; 80: 40.     CrossRef
    • Do Sociology Courses Make More Empathetic Students? A Mixed-Methods Study of Empathy Change in Undergraduates
      Ashley Rockwell, Chris M. Vidmar, Penny Harvey, Leanna Greenwood
      Teaching Sociology.2019; 47(4): 284.     CrossRef
    • How does medical education affect empathy and compassion in medical students? A meta-ethnography: BEME Guide No. 57
      Charmaine Krishnasamy, Sik Yin Ong, May Eng Loo, Jill Thistlethwaite
      Medical Teacher.2019; 41(11): 1220.     CrossRef
    • Developing EFL students’ digital empathy through video production
      Cheryl Wei-yu Chen
      System.2018; 77: 50.     CrossRef
    • Use of mixed-methods approach to assess the impact of a pre-professional health humanities honors course on developing interpersonal skills
      Haley N. Ilcewicz, Therese I. Poirier, Junvie Pailden
      Currents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning.2018; 10(11): 1456.     CrossRef
    • Narrative Praxis: Erzählungen als Vermittler zwischen Erfahrungswelten im Gesundheitswesen
      Vera Kalitzkus
      Leidfaden.2018; 7(4): 37.     CrossRef
    • Narrative medicine educational project to improve the care of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
      Antonietta Cappuccio, Alessandro Sanduzzi Zamparelli, Massimo Verga, Stefano Nardini, Alessandro Policreti, Pasquale Alberto Porpiglia, Silvia Napolitano, Maria Giulia Marini
      ERJ Open Research.2018; 4(2): 00155-2017.     CrossRef
    • Goals of care conversation teaching in residency – a cross-sectional survey of postgraduate program directors
      Amanda Roze des Ordons, Aliya Kassam, Jessica Simon
      BMC Medical Education.2017;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • What Do Pediatric Residents Gain From an Experience in Juvenile Justice? A Qualitative Analysis of Community-Based Learning
      Elizabeth R. Hanson, Erin P. Finley, Jean A. Petershack
      Academic Pediatrics.2017; 17(3): 296.     CrossRef
    • Exploring the Facets of Empathy and Pain in Clinical Practice: A Review
      Jenny Roche, Dominic Harmon
      Pain Practice.2017; 17(8): 1089.     CrossRef
    • Student perceptions of the impact and value of incorporation of reflective writing across a pharmacy curriculum
      Amber E. King, Andrea S. Joseph, Elena M. Umland
      Currents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning.2017; 9(5): 770.     CrossRef
    • Efficacy of empathy training in nursing students: A quasi-experimental study
      Pilar Bas-Sarmiento, Martina Fernández-Gutiérrez, María Baena-Baños, Jose Manuel Romero-Sánchez
      Nurse Education Today.2017; 59: 59.     CrossRef
    • Medical Students’ Empathy for Vulnerable Groups: Results From a Survey and Reflective Writing Assignment
      Caroline Wellbery, Pamela A. Saunders, Sarah Kureshi, Adam Visconti
      Academic Medicine.2017; 92(12): 1709.     CrossRef
    • Meeting the Challenge of a More Person-Centered Future for us Healthcare
      Bonnie R. Sakallaris, William L. Miller, Robert Saper, Mary Jo Kreitzer, Wayne Jonas
      Global Advances in Health and Medicine.2016; 5(1): 51.     CrossRef
    • Medical students’ creative projects on a third year pediatrics clerkship: a qualitative analysis of patient-centeredness and emotional connection
      Johanna Shapiro, Diane Ortiz, You Ye Ree, Minha Sarwar
      BMC Medical Education.2016;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • The Emerging Issue of Digital Empathy
      Christopher Terry, Jeff Cain
      American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education.2016; 80(4): 58.     CrossRef
    • Reflective Practice in Healthcare Education: An Umbrella Review
      Konstantinos Fragkos
      Education Sciences.2016; 6(3): 27.     CrossRef
    • La formazione alle soft skills nel Corso di laurea in Medicina: uno studio qualitativo sulle scritture riflessive di un campione di studenti
      Lucia Zannini, Maria Benedetta Gambacorti-Passerini, Pier Maria Battezzati
      EDUCATIONAL REFLECTIVE PRACTICES.2016; (2): 9.     CrossRef
    • Reflective Writing
      David M. Naeger, Ethan W. Hua, Bren Ahearn, Emily M. Webb
      Academic Radiology.2015; 22(10): 1221.     CrossRef
    • Considerations in the use of reflective writing for student assessment: issues of reliability and validity
      Tracy Moniz, Shannon Arntfield, Kristina Miller, Lorelei Lingard, Chris Watling, Glenn Regehr
      Medical Education.2015; 49(9): 901.     CrossRef
    • Professional Identity Formation in Medical Education for Humanistic, Resilient Physicians
      Hedy S. Wald, David Anthony, Tom A. Hutchinson, Stephen Liben, Mark Smilovitch, Anthony A. Donato
      Academic Medicine.2015; 90(6): 753.     CrossRef
    • Learning from Primary Health Care Centers in Nepal: reflective writings on experiential learning of third year Nepalese medical students
      Rolina Dhital, Madhusudan Subedi, Neeti Prasai, Karun Shrestha, Milan Malla, Shambhu Upadhyay
      BMC Research Notes.2015;[Epub]     CrossRef
    • One-Year Progress in Ophthalmic Education
      Eduardo Mayorga, Karl Golnik, Gabriela Palis
      Asia-Pacific Journal of Ophthalmology.2015; 4(6): 388.     CrossRef

    Related articles
    Reflective writing and its impact on empathy in medical education: systematic review
    Reflective writing and its impact on empathy in medical education: systematic review
    Study Country Population studied Intervention protocol
    Haack and Phillips, 2012 [19] USA 135 PharmD students Cohort study on a cultural competency course with a renewed curriculum. Group and individual reflection activities following lectures and clinical encounters, including a reflective paper.
    Lie et al., 2010 [17] USA 376 Medical students Guided written reflection following clinic encounters, performed in small groups over a 4-week family practice elective.
    Lonie and Rahim, 2010 [18] USA 210 Pharmacy students The addition of a reflective writing component to a communication skills course over one semester. This included two short (3–5 page) and one long (6–8 page) reflective papers.
    Plake, 2010 [21] USA 20 Pharmacy students Weekly written reflections in a book club focusing on novels describing patients’ experiences with chronic illness.
    Roche, 2007 [20] USA 15 Pharmacy students Reflective journals kept following readings and discussions in a Native American service learning elective.
    Shapiro et al., 2006 [22] USA 92 Medical students Students randomized to point-of-view reflective writing or clinical reasoning style of writing for monthly essays following simulated patient modules.
    Wallman et al., 2008 [24] Sweden 146 Pharmacy students Pre- and post-course reflective essays for a 6 month pharmacy internship experience.
    Westmoreland et al., 2009 [23] USA 237 Medical students Pre- and post-reflective writing for meeting sessions with a geriatric population.
    Study Outcome(s) measured Result
    Haack and Phillips, 2012 [19] Cultural competency through the Inventory to Assess the Process of Cultural Competence-revised (IAPCC-R): a validated self-assessment tool. Overall cultural competency did not differ between intervention and non-intervention groups, but cultural skills and cultural encounters scores were higher for the intervention group.
    Lie et al., 2010 [17] An assessment questionnaire to quantify the new course’s relevance in preparing students for a cross-cultural practice; a pre- and post-essay style test on cultural competency. The students’responses were 83% positive for the course, and they showed a statistically significant score improvement on the post-test relative to the pre-test.
    Lonie and Rahim, 2010 [18] Objective Structure Clinical Examination (OSCE) scores and multiple choice examinations for a communications course. A statistically significant increase in multiple choice scores was observed in the intervention group, with no change in OSCE scores.
    Plake, 2010 [21] After the elective, students completed retrospective surveys (5-point Likert scale) on their perceived functional empathy before and after the course. Students showed statistically significant increases in self-assessed ability to complete empathy and compassion related tasks.
    Roche, 2007 [20] A post survey evaluation of course objectives, including empathy-related statements regarding underserved populations. Researchers found significant improvements in students’“cultural appreciation and respect, awareness of health disparities and the need for social responsibility, appreciation for the spiritual aspect of wellness, and the positive impact of traditions on health, and a recognition of professionally rewarding practice opportunities.”
    Shapiro et al., 2006 [22] OSCE exams scores were compared. The two groups did not differ on OSCE exam scores, but in the essay point-of-view writers were more likely to adopt the first person, to show empathy for the physician, and showed a higher score in overall empathy and insight.
    Wallman et al., 2008 [24] Essays were graded on a rubric of level of reflection with good inter-rater reliability (k5 = 0.63). The levels of reflection scored in the essays pre- and post-course increased significantly.
    Westmoreland et al., 2009 [23] Reflective writing was analyzed for themes as a means of assessing changing attitudes and perceptions toward the elderly; a written pre- and post-survey on geriatric attitudes was administered; a learner satisfaction survey was administered. Reflective writing analysis found a change in perception of elderly: 27% of participants changed their negative into positive or reinforced their pre-existing positive attitudes. 98% of students were also satisfied with the learning experience delivered by the sessions and writing exercises.
    Table 1. Study locations, populations, and intervention protocols

    Table 2. Study outcomes and conclusions

    Table 1.

    Table 2.

    JEEHP : Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions
    © Korea Health Personnel Licensing Examination Institute.
    TOP