Purpose This study aimed to assess the impact of ultrasound simulation (SonoSim) on educational outcomes of an introductory point-of-care ultrasound course compared to hands-on training with live models alone. Methods: Fifty-three internal medicine residents without ultrasound experience were randomly assigned to control or experimental groups. They participated in an introductory point-of-care ultrasound course covering eight topics in eight sessions from June 23, 2014 until July 18, 2014. Both participated in lecture and hands-on training, but experimental group received an hour of computerized simulator training instead of a second hour of hands-on training. We assessed clinical knowledge and image acquisition with written multiple-choice and practical exams, respectively. Of the 53 enrolled, 40 participants (75.5%) completed the course and all testing. Results: For the 30-item written exam, mean score of the experimental group was 23.1±3.4 (n=21) vs. 21.8±4.8 (n=19), (P>0 .05). For the practical exam, mean score for both groups was 8.7 out of 16 (P>0 .05). Conclusion: The substitution of eight hours of ultrasound simulation training for live model scanning in a 24 hour training course did not enhance performance on written and image acquisition tests in an introductory ultrasound course for residents. This result suggests that ultrasound simulation technology used as a substitute for live model training on an hour-for-hour basis, did not improve learning outcomes. Further investigation into simulation as a total replacement for live model training will provide a clearer picture of the efficacy of ultrasound simulators in medical education.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Ultrasound diagnostics in solving situational problems in the discipline of clinical pathophysiology A. B. Makarov, V. N. Tsygan, A. V. Lemeshchenko, M. V. Rezvantsev, T. A. Krivolutskaya, T. A. Bammatov Pacific Medical Journal.2024; (4): 97. CrossRef
Point-of-Care Ultrasound in the Intensive Care Unit Yonatan Y. Greenstein, Keith Guevarra Clinics in Chest Medicine.2022; 43(3): 373. CrossRef
SonoSim ultrasound simulator training for novice residents Antoine Frère, Esther Samba, Corinne Lejus-Bourdeau European Journal of Anaesthesiology.2021; 38(7): 791. CrossRef
Ultrasound in Medical Education: Can Students Teach Themselves? Brandon Cowan, Abigail Brackney, Mallikarjuna Barremkala Medical Science Educator.2021; 31(5): 1663. CrossRef
Determining if simulation is effective for training in ultrasound: A narrative review Kate Bradley, Ann Quinton, Aamer Aziz Sonography.2020; 7(1): 22. CrossRef
Impact of a 4-hour Introductory eFAST Training Intervention Among Ultrasound-Naïve U.S. Military Medics Jonathan D Monti, Michael D Perreault Military Medicine.2020; 185(5-6): e601. CrossRef
The long-term effect of short point of care ultrasound course on physicians’ daily practice Ortal Tuvali, Re'em Sadeh, Sergio Kobal, Shaked Yarza, Yael Golan, Lior Fuchs, Etsuro Ito PLOS ONE.2020; 15(11): e0242084. CrossRef
Developing Neuraxial and Regional Pain Procedural Skills Through Innovative 3-Dimensional Printing Technology Zachary C. Headman, Marcus C. Matson, Robert P. Schneider, James L. Potter, Debra L. Loguda-Summers, Shalini Bhatia, Tatyana Kondrashova Journal of Osteopathic Medicine.2020; 120(4): 273. CrossRef
The Use of Ultrasound Simulators to Strengthen Scanning Skills in Medical Students: A Randomized Controlled Trial Cathie‐Kim Le, John Lewis, Peter Steinmetz, Alina Dyachenko, Sharon Oleskevich Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine.2019; 38(5): 1249. CrossRef
Impact of an intensive education programme of diagnostic lung and lower limb ultrasound on physiotherapist knowledge: A pilot study George Ntoumenopoulos, Selina M. Parry, Aymeric Le Neindre Australasian Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine.2018; 21(2): 104. CrossRef
Point-of-Care Ultrasound for Internal Medicine: An International Perspective Irene W. Y. Ma, Chiara Cogliati, Frank H. Bosch, Ana Claudia Tonelli de Oliveira, Vincenzo Arienti, Michiel J. Blans, Barry Chan, Anjali Bhagra Southern Medical Journal.2018; 111(7): 439. CrossRef
Développement d’un examen clinique objectif structuré (ECOS) pour évaluer les compétences des étudiants en médecine vasculaire J. Risse, T. Busato, V. Dufrost, M. Perri, S. Zuily, D. Wahl JMV-Journal de Médecine Vasculaire.2017; 42(3): 141. CrossRef
Enhancing Learning Experience Using Ultrasound Simulation in Undergraduate Medical Education: Student Perception Tatyana Kondrashova, Crystal Coleman Medical Science Educator.2017; 27(3): 489. CrossRef
Evaluation of a pilot programme on diagnostic thoracic ultrasound curriculum for acute care physiotherapists George Ntoumenopoulos, Hwee Kuan Ong, Hong Chuen Toh, Rafael Pulido Saclolo, Wen Duu Sewa Australasian Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine.2017; 20(4): 147. CrossRef