Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions

Review

How to execute Context, Input, Process, and Product evaluation model in medical health education: So young Lee, Jwa-Seop Shin, Seung-Hee Lee; J Educ Eval Health Prof. 2019;16:40. Published online December 28, 2019; DOI: https://doi.org/10.3352/jeehp.2019.16.40

22,146 View
918 Download
24 Web of Science
29 Crossref

Improvements to education are necessary in order to keep up with the education requirements of today. The Context, Input, Process, and Product (CIPP) evaluation model was created for the decision-making towards education improvement, so this model is appropriate in this regard. However, application of this model in the actual context of medical health education is considered difficult in the education environment. Thus, in this study, literature survey of previous studies was investigated to examine the execution procedure of how the CIPP model can be actually applied. For the execution procedure utilizing the CIPP model, the criteria and indicators were determined from analysis results and material was collected after setting the material collection method. Afterwards, the collected material was analyzed for each CIPP element, and finally, the relationship of each CIPP element was analyzed for the final improvement decision-making. In this study, these steps were followed and the methods employed in previous studies were organized. Particularly, the process of determining the criteria and indicators was important and required a significant effort. Literature survey was carried out to analyze the most widely used criteria through content analysis and obtained a total of 12 criteria. Additional emphasis is necessary in the importance of the criteria selection for the actual application of the CIPP model. Also, a diverse range of information can be obtained through qualitative as well as quantitative methods. Above all, since the CIPP evaluation model execution result becomes the basis for the execution of further improved evaluations, the first attempt of performing without hesitation is essential.

Citations

Citations to this article as recorded by

Beyond Surveys: Unveiling the Impact of Focus Group Interviews in Medical Education Evaluation
Selçuk Akturan, Ayşenur Duman Dilbaz, Yasemin Güner, Melek Üçüncüoğlu, Neşe Kaklıkkaya
Genel Tıp Dergisi.2026;[Epub] CrossRef
The Correctional Nursing Workforce Crisis: An Innovative Solution to Meet the Challenge
Deborah Shelton, Lori E. Roscoe, Theresa A. Kapetanovic, Sue Smith
Journal of Correctional Health Care.2025; 31(2): 82. CrossRef
A Novel Implementation of the CIPP Model in Undergraduate Medical Education: The Karadeniz Technical University Faculty of Medicine Experience
Selçuk Akturan
Tıp Eğitimi Dünyası.2025; 24(72): 5. CrossRef
The structural effects of evaluation types in the implementation process of the independent learning program in higher education
Bambang Budi Wiyono, Aan Komariah, Hendra Hidayat, Desi Eri Kusumaningrum
Discover Sustainability.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Implementation of the CIPP Model for Assessing the Elements of Archive Management Based on The Independent Curriculum
Ananda Destya Selviana, Ismiyati, Mar'atus Sholikah
Jurnal Pendidikan dan Pengajaran.2025; 58(1): 172. CrossRef
Enhancing Health Policy Administration in LMICs: Dr. LJW Fellowship Program Insights (2021–2023)
Bomgyeol Kim, Yejin Kim, Jun Su Park, Soo Hyeok Choi, Su Hyun Kim, Vasuki Rajaguru, Hyejin Jung, Tae Hyun Kim
Annals of Global Health.2025; 91(1): 34. CrossRef
Evaluation of Self-Directed Learning Activities at King Abdulaziz University: A Qualitative Study of Faculty Perceptions
Ammar A Balkheyour, Michal Tombs
Cureus.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Educational and research utility of the registrar clinical encounters in training (ReCEnT) project: an exploration of mechanisms using the context, input, process and product (CIPP) framework
Michael Tran, Susan Wearne, Andrew Davey, Parker Magin
Family Medicine and Community Health.2025; 13(3): e003289. CrossRef
Raising expectations and defining boundaries in quality management scholarship: Strengthening the design, methodology, and reporting of quality-focused work
Paul Simpson, Walter Tavares
Paramedicine.2025; 22(5): 221. CrossRef
Application of multidisciplinary collaborative education in general clinical training based on the CIPP model: a comparative study
Xia Li, Qinggan Ni, Jing Zhou, Shanshan Pang, Yingling Zhu, Wenchun Song
Critical Public Health.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
A structured, mentored experiential clinical research programme for undergraduate students
MINAKSHI PARIKH, PURVI BHAGAT, AMITA HIMANSHU SUTARIA, SAMYAK BHARWAD, HARIOM VAJA, AHAN BANKER, KHUSHI SHAH, HANSA MOTIGIRI GOSWAMI
The National Medical Journal of India.2025; 0: 1. CrossRef
A satisfaction-focused CIPP evaluation of Mongolia’s undergraduate occupational therapy program: a cross-sectional study
Bulganchimeg Sanjmyatav, Erdenetsetseg Myagmar, Karen P. Y. Liu, Janet Lok Chun Lee, Munkh-Erdene Bayartai, Batgerel Oidov, Solongo Bandi, Oyungoo Badamdorj
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2025; 37(4): 391. CrossRef
Klinik Beceri Eğitiminin Değerlendirilmesinde CIPP Modeli: Teoriden Uygulamaya
Selcen Öncü, Özlem Sürel Karabilgin Öztürkçü
Tıp Eğitimi Dünyası.2025; 24(74): 153. CrossRef
Evaluation of the pencak silat coaching program in East Java: A study using the CIPP model
Heri Wahyudi, Roy Januardi Irawan, Achmad Widodo, Mokhamad Nur Bawono, Himawan Wismanadi, Shidqi Hamdi Pratama Putera, Anindya Mar’atus Sholikhah, Dhananjaya Sutanto
SPORT TK-Revista EuroAmericana de Ciencias del Deporte.2025; 14: 77. CrossRef
Evaluation of the Maryland Next Gen Test Bank Project: Implications and Recommendations
Desirée Hensel, Diane M. Billings, Rebecca Wiseman
Nursing Education Perspectives.2024; 45(4): 225. CrossRef
Development of a blended teaching quality evaluation scale (BTQES) for undergraduate nursing based on the Context, Input, Process and Product (CIPP) evaluation model: A cross-sectional survey
Yue Zhao, Weijuan Li, Hong Jiang, Mohedesi Siyiti, Meng Zhao, Shuping You, Yinglan Li, Ping Yan
Nurse Education in Practice.2024; 77: 103976. CrossRef
Internal evaluation of medical programs is more than housework: A scoping review
Sujani Kodagoda Gamage, Tanisha Jowsey, Jo Bishop, Melanie Forbes, Lucy-Jane Grant, Patricia Green, Helen Houghton, Matthew Links, Mark Morgan, Joan Roehl, Jessica Stokes-Parish, Rano Mal Piryani
PLOS ONE.2024; 19(10): e0305996. CrossRef
Effectiveness of Peer-Assisted Learning in health professional education: a scoping review of systematic reviews
Hanbo Feng, Ziyi Luo, Zijing Wu, Xiaohan Li
BMC Medical Education.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Pengembangan Budaya Integritas Melalui Pendekatan Sufistik pada Perguruan Tinggi Berbasis Pesantren
Imaduddin Imaduddin
Nidhomiyyah: Jurnal Manajemen Pendidikan Islam.2024; 5(1): 66. CrossRef
Evaluating the Economics Education Framework Within the Merdeka Curriculum at the Ecd Level: Case Study at Kharisma Kindergarten
Fariha Nuraini, Annisa Mar’atus Sholikhah, Wahjoedi, Farida Rahmawati
Eduscape : Journal of Education Insight.2024; 2(3): 186. CrossRef
Self-care educational guide for mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus: A systematic review on identifying self-care domains, approaches, and their effectiveness
Zarina Haron, Rosnah Sutan, Roshaya Zakaria, Zaleha Abdullah Mahdy
Belitung Nursing Journal.2023; 9(1): 6. CrossRef
Evaluation of the Smart Indonesia Program as a Policy to Improve Equality in Education
Patni Ninghardjanti, Wiedy Murtini, Aniek Hindrayani, Khresna B. Sangka
Sustainability.2023; 15(6): 5114. CrossRef
Exploring Perceptions of Competency-Based Medical Education in Undergraduate Medical Students and Faculty: A Program Evaluation
Erica Ai Li, Claire A Wilson, Jacob Davidson, Aaron Kwong, Amrit Kirpalani, Peter Zhan Tao Wang
Advances in Medical Education and Practice.2023; Volume 14: 381. CrossRef
The Evaluation of China's Double Reduction Policy: A Case Study in Dongming County Mingde Primary School
Danyang Li , Chaimongkhon Supromin, Supit Boonlab
International Journal of Sociologies and Anthropologies Science Reviews.2023; 3(6): 437. CrossRef
Exploring the Components of the Research Empowerment Program of the Faculty Members of Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Iran Based on the CIPP Model: A Qualitative Study
Mostafa Jafari, Susan Laei, Elham Kavyani, Rostam Jalali
Educational Research in Medical Sciences.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Adapting an Integrated Program Evaluation for Promoting Competency‐Based Medical Education
Hyunjung Ju, Minkyung Oh, Jong-Tae Lee, Bo Young Yoon
Korean Medical Education Review.2021; 23(1): 56. CrossRef
Changes in the accreditation standards of medical schools by the Korean Institute of Medical Education and Evaluation from 2000 to 2019
Hyo Hyun Yoo, Mi Kyung Kim, Yoo Sang Yoon, Keun Mi Lee, Jong Hun Lee, Seung-Jae Hong, Jung –Sik Huh, Won Kyun Park
Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions.2020; 17: 2. CrossRef
Human Resources Development via Higher Education Scholarships: A Case Study of a Ministry of Public Works and Housing Scholarship Program
Abdullatif SETİABUDİ, Muchlis. R. LUDDIN, Yuli RAHMAWATI
International e-Journal of Educational Studies.2020; 4(8): 209. CrossRef
Exploring Components, Barriers, and Solutions for Faculty Members’ Research Empowerment Programs Based on the CIPP Model: A Qualitative Study
Mostafa Jafari, Soosan Laei, Elham Kavyani, Rostam Jalali
Journal of Occupational Health and Epidemiology.2020; 9(4): 213. CrossRef

Research Article

Evaluation of a continuing professional development training program for physicians and physician assistants in hospitals in Laos based on the Kirkpatrick model: Hyun Bae Yoon, Jwa-Seop Shin, Ketsomsouk Bouphavanh, Yu Min Kang; J Educ Eval Health Prof. 2016;13:21. Published online May 31, 2016; DOI: https://doi.org/10.3352/jeehp.2016.13.21

34,166 View
360 Download
25 Web of Science
23 Crossref

Abstract PDF

Purpose
Medical professionals from Korea and Laos have been working together to develop a continuing professional development training program covering the major clinical fields of primary care. This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of the program from 2013 to 2014 using the Kirkpatrick model. Methods: A questionnaire was used to evaluate the reaction of the trainees, and the trainers assessed the level of trainees’ performance at the beginning and the end of each clinical section. The transfer (behavioral change) of the trainees was evaluated through the review of medical records written by the trainees before and after the training program. Results: The trainees were satisfied with the training program, for which the average score was 4.48 out of 5.0. The average score of the trainees’ performance at the beginning was 2.39 out of 5.0, and rose to 3.88 at the end of each section. The average score of the medical records written before the training was 2.92 out of 5.0, and it rose to 3.34 after the training. The number of patient visits to the district hospitals increased. Conclusion: The continuing professional development training program, which was planned and implemented with the full engagement and responsibility of Lao health professionals, proved to be effective.

Citations

Citations to this article as recorded by

An evaluation of pre-post antimicrobial stewardship healthcare educational intervention studies utilizing the Kirkpatrick model: a scoping review
Ziad G. Nasr, Hanin M. Said, Kaoutar R. Barakat, Raghad M. Elwan, Aya Maklad, Zachariah J. Nazar
International Journal of Clinical Pharmacy.2025; 47(6): 1635. CrossRef
Practicalities and dichotomies of education policy and practice of higher education in the Golden Triangle Area (Southeast Asia): Implications for international development
Shine Wanna Aung, Than Than Aye
Policy Futures in Education.2024; 22(7): 1421. CrossRef
Evaluation of cost-effectiveness of single-credit traffic safety course based on Kirkpatrick model: a case study of Iran
Mina Golestani, Homayoun Sadeghi-bazargani, Sepideh Harzand-Jadidi, Hamid Soori
BMC Medical Education.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Effectiveness of E-learning on “Sexual Health” among students of Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences based on the Kirkpatrick model
Zohreh Sadat Mirmoghtadaie, Zahra Mahbadi, Zinat Mahbadi
Journal of Education and Health Promotion.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
The benefits and limitations of establishing the PA profession globally
Arden R. Turkewitz, Jane P. Sallen, Rachel M. Smith, Kandi Pitchford, Kimberly Lay, Scott Smalley
JAAPA.2024; 37(11): 1. CrossRef
Transforming the “SEAD”: Evaluation of a Virtual Surgical Exploration and Discovery Program and its Effects on Career Decision-Making
Kameela Miriam Alibhai, Patricia Burhunduli, Christopher Tarzi, Kush Patel, Christine Seabrook, Tim Brandys
Journal of Surgical Education.2023; 80(2): 256. CrossRef
Evaluation of the effectiveness of a training programme for nurses regarding augmentative and alternative communication with intubated patients using Kirkpatrick's model: A pilot study
Marzieh Momennasab, Fatemeh Mohammadi, Fereshteh DehghanRad, Azita Jaberi
Nursing Open.2023; 10(5): 2895. CrossRef
Outcome Evaluation of a Transnational Postgraduate Capacity-Building Program Using the Objective Structured Clinical Examination
Kye-Yeung Park, Hoon-Ki Park, Jwa-Seop Shin, Taejong Kim, Youngjoo Jung, Min Young Seo, Ketsomsouk Bouphavanh, Sourideth Sengchanh, Ketmany Inthachack
Evaluation Review.2023; 47(4): 680. CrossRef
Developing a capacity building training model for public health managers of low and middle income countries
Kritika Upadhyay, Sonu Goel, Preethi John, Sara Rubinelli
PLOS ONE.2023; 18(4): e0272793. CrossRef
Portfolios with Evidence of Reflective Practice Required by Regulatory Bodies: An Integrative Review
Marco Zaccagnini, Patricia A. Miller
Physiotherapy Canada.2022; 74(4): 330. CrossRef
Implementation and evaluation of crowdsourcing in global health education
Huanle Cai, Huiqiong Zheng, Jinghua Li, Chun Hao, Jing Gu, Jing Liao, Yuantao Hao
Global Health Research and Policy.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
An Evaluation of the Surgical Foundations Curriculum: A National Study
Ekaterina Kouzmina, Stephen Mann, Timothy Chaplin, Boris Zevin
Journal of Surgical Education.2021; 78(3): 914. CrossRef
Surgical data strengthening in Ethiopia: results of a Kirkpatrick framework evaluation of a data quality intervention
Sehrish Bari, Joseph Incorvia, Katherine R. Iverson, Abebe Bekele, Kaya Garringer, Olivia Ahearn, Laura Drown, Amanu Aragaw Emiru, Daniel Burssa, Samson Workineh, Ephrem Daniel Sheferaw, John G. Meara, Andualem Beyene
Global Health Action.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Evaluation of a Neonatal Resuscitation Training Programme for Healthcare Professionals in Zanzibar, Tanzania: A Pre-post Intervention Study
Xiang Ding, Li Wang, Mwinyi I. Msellem, Yaojia Hu, Jun Qiu, Shiying Liu, Mi Zhang, Lihui Zhu, Jos M. Latour
Frontiers in Pediatrics.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Building Capacity of Programme Managers under National Health Mission on Public Health Management and Leadership: Experiences and Way Forward
Sonu Goel, Kritika Upadhyay, BK Padhi
Health and Population: Perspectives and Issues.2021; 44(3): 140. CrossRef
Evaluation of a training program on primary eye care for an Accredited Social Health Activist (ASHA) in an urban district
Pallavi Shukla, Praveen Vashist, SurajSingh Senjam, Vivek Gupta
Indian Journal of Ophthalmology.2020; 68(2): 356. CrossRef
Micro-feedback skills workshop impacts perceptions and practices of doctoral faculty
Najma Baseer, James Degnan, Mandy Moffat, Usman Mahboob
BMC Medical Education.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Residents working with Médecins Sans Frontières: training and pilot evaluation
Alba Ripoll-Gallardo, Luca Ragazzoni, Ettore Mazzanti, Grazia Meneghetti, Jeffrey Michael Franc, Alessandro Costa, Francesco della Corte
Scandinavian Journal of Trauma, Resuscitation and Emergency Medicine.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
The effectiveness of in-service training “pharmacopeia home health” based on Kirkpatrick's model: A quasi-experimental study
Mahtab Firooznia, Amir Hamta, Sareh Shakerian
Journal of Education and Health Promotion.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Medical education in Laos
Timothy Alan Wittick, Ketsomsouk Bouphavanh, Vannyda Namvongsa, Amphay Khounthep, Amy Gray
Medical Teacher.2019; 41(8): 877. CrossRef
Evaluation of the effectiveness of a first aid health volunteers’ training programme using Kirkpatrick’s model: A pilot study
Fatemeh Vizeshfar, Marzieh Momennasab, Shahrzad Yektatalab, Mohamad Taghi Iman
Health Education Journal.2018; 77(2): 190. CrossRef
Evaluation of a consulting training course for international development assistance for health
Pan Gao, Hao Xiang, Suyang Liu, Yisi Liu, Shengjie Dong, Feifei Liu, Wenyuan Yu, Xiangyu Li, Li Guan, Yuanyuan Chu, Zongfu Mao, Shu Chen, Shenglan Tang
BMC Medical Education.2018;[Epub] CrossRef
Empowering the Filipino Physician through Continuing Professional Development in the Philippines: Gearing towards ASEAN Harmonization and Globalization
Maria Minerva P Calimag
Journal of Medicine, University of Santo Tomas.2018; 2(1): 121. CrossRef

First
Prev
Page of 1
Next
Last

Search